Nocturnal at Noon? Addressing False Positives in Activity Pattern Data

Read full text
Authors: Mohamed Khalil Meliane, Nicole Rita, Zachery B. Holmes, Joseph M. Guthrie, E. Hance Ellington
Cited by: 1
References: 9

Abstract

False positives in wildlife detection datasets can substantially bias ecological inference, including diel activity pattern estimation from time-stamped detections. This problem is intensifying with widespread use of automated classifiers for camera-trap images and bioacoustic recordings, where full human verification is rarely feasible. Here, we present a Bayesian framework that provides a false-positive-aware alternative to commonly used pooled kernel density estimation workflows for diel activity. The model uses a subset of human-verified records to estimate (i) θ, the dataset-average true-positive rate among apparent detections, and (ii) time-of-day distributions describing the relative frequency of true detections and false positives across the 24-h cycle. We implement two error structures: a parsimonious uniform false-positive model and a flexible "skewed" model that learns a false-positive diel distribution to accommodate temporally clustered misclassifications. Simulations across multiple activity shapes, false-positive rates, and verification intensities showed that the approach can recover true diel patterns with limited verification effort and reduces bias relative to uncorrected estimates. We illustrate the method on an empirical dataset, where accounting for false positives yielded meaningfully different activity inferences than standard pooled approaches. Finally, we discuss extensions that allow θ to vary with covariates or random effects (e.g., site/night) and highlight opportunities to integrate diel activity correction with modern false-positive occupancy and abundance models.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Animal Vocal Communication and Behavior Wildlife Ecology and Conservation Wildlife-Road Interactions and Conservation

Publication details

Journal / source
Ecology and Evolution
Publisher
Wiley
Volume
16
Issue
4
Pages
e73388–e73388
Publication date
30 March 2026
Language
EN