Analyzing instructor facilitation patterns in debriefings using AI-based speech metrics

Read full text
Authors: Soledad Armijo-Rivera, Scarlett Vicencio-Clarke, Hernán Caamaño, Pía Díaz, Carla Pino, Francesca Caldo, Daniel Herrera, Carlos Hinrichsen
Cited by: 1
References: 11

Abstract

Background Facilitation of debriefings is critical for fostering reflection and behavioral change. However, little is known about how novice instructors distribute their speaking time and how this impacts perceived debriefing quality. Artificial intelligence (AI)-driven conversational analysis offers an objective method to characterize facilitation patterns. Methods Participants were fifteen novice healthcare instructors with less than one year of experience who recently completed an online simulation course. A cross-sectional study was conducted using GailBot API for automated transcription and speech analysis of remote interprofessional debriefings. Standardized scenarios and consistent student participants controlled external variables. Instructor facilitation patterns were compared to DASH evaluations from students, instructors, and an expert observer. Results Instructors spoke for an average of 56.09% of debriefing time. Higher instructor talk time correlated negatively with DASH self-ratings (Spearman's Rho=−0.627, p = .012). Conclusion AI-based analysis provides valuable insights into facilitation patterns, supporting multidisciplinary faculty development.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Intelligent Tutoring Systems and Adaptive Learning Speech and dialogue systems Team Dynamics and Performance

Publication details

Journal / source
Clinical Simulation in Nursing
Publisher
Elsevier BV
Volume
112
Pages
101897–101897
Publication date
30 January 2026
Language
EN