More than Watts and Dollars: Reframing energy planning through an ontological–ethical lens

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Nelber Ximenes Melo, Christian Maciel de Britto, Jonathan Simões Freitas, Gustavo R. S. Assi
Cited by: 0
References: 75

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Contemporary energy planning remains largely dominated by technical and economic optimization, often overlooking the ethical and ontological dimensions that shape sociotechnical systems. This reductionist orientation contributes to persistent failures in achieving just and sustainable energy transitions. This article argues that such failures stem from two interrelated philosophical gaps: ontological reductionism that narrows the understanding of energy systems, and an ethical deficit that marginalizes justice-related values. To address these gaps, this study develops a normative framework that integrates key concepts from the philosophy of technology, particularly Dooyeweerd’s theory of modal aspects, Jonas’s ethics of responsibility, and MacIntyre’s virtue ethics. These foundations are operationalized through an adapted Value Sensitive Design (VSD) methodology. The resulting framework provides a conceptual lens for diagnosing neglected aspects of energy planning and a methodological structure for incorporating stakeholder values into design processes. The analysis yields a set of six guiding principles: non-reductionism, subsidiarity, participation, equity, communitarianism, and resilience. These principles articulate how ethical and ontological considerations can inform energy system design and planning. Together, they offer a normative orientation that complements technocratic approaches and supports context-sensitive, socially responsible energy transitions. By reframing energy planning through an ontological–ethical lens, this study establishes a methodological bridge between philosophy of technology and energy justice research. It also identifies conceptual and methodological pathways for embedding normative reflection within the transformation of energy systems.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Sustainability and Climate Change Governance Social Acceptance of Renewable Energy Environmental Philosophy and Ethics

Publication details

Journal / source
Energy Research & Social Science
Volume
135
Pages
104655–104655
Publication date
27 March 2026
Language
EN