When Fear Feels Like Fact

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Thomas J. Fiedorek, Brian K. Eble, Joshua August Daily
Cited by: 0
References: 5

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

In January 2023, the sports world watched in shock as Damar Hamlin, a safety for the Buffalo Bills of the National Football League, collapsed from commotio cordis on national television during Monday Night Football.In the immediate aftermath, our pediatric cardiology clinics experienced a surge of anxious families.Parents of healthy athletes-who had played safely for years-suddenly visualized what they had never imagined: that each game or practice could be their child's last.The epidemiology of sudden cardiac death in athletes did not change that night, but the perception of it did.This Viewpoint article explores the cognitive biases that distort how cardiac risk in sports is understood and offers strategies to help clinicians reframe these fears. THE TRUE RISKSudden cardiac death remains exceptionally uncommon in young athletes, with large cohort studies demonstrating approximately 0.24 to 6.8 deaths per 100,000 athlete-years. 1 While much attention is focused on rare cardiac risks, sports participation provides substantial protective benefits-not only for cardiovascular health, but also for emotional well-being, identity formation, resilience, social connection, and mental health.2,3 Conversely, inactivity carries equally serious but far more common risks, including obesity, hypertension, depression, and anxiety.2,4,5 THE PSYCHOLOGY OF PERCEIVED RISKWhen a young athlete collapses on television, families do not interpret the moment from an epidemiological standpoint, but from a psychological one.Emotion, uncertainty, and vivid imagery activate heuristicsadaptive mental shortcuts shaped to favor survival, respond to threat, and guide action when information is incomplete.However, when faced with a rare, frightening event such as sudden cardiac arrest in an athlete, those same heuristics can misfire.What normally aids efficient thinking becomes distorted, producing cognitive biases that exaggerate rare, dramatic risks while obscuring more common but equally consequential harms, including those related to inactivity, isolation, or mental health.In sports cardiology, these distortions tend to fall into 4 recurring patterns: emotion-driven bias, probability distortion, social amplification, and clinician susceptibility (Table 1). EMOTION-DRIVEN DISTORTIONS: WHEN FEAR FEELS LIKE FACT.Highly emotional and memorable eventslike a televised cardiac arrest-feel more common than they are.The availability and affect heuristics amplify

Fields of Study & Subjects

Cardiovascular Effects of Exercise Clinical Reasoning and Diagnostic Skills Decision-Making and Behavioral Economics

Publication details

Journal / source
JACC Case Reports
Volume
31
Issue
12
Pages
107010–107010
Publication date
1 March 2026
Language
EN