The peril of requesting additional studies
Summary
No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.
Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.Abstract
Allen et al. (2026) make a compelling case that the shift toward developmental reviewing has negative consequences.I agree with their premise, and I want to highlight a particular practice I believe is especially problematic: the all-too-common instruction from reviewers and editors to "conduct an additional study."This request is the epitome of the developmental approach, and I believe it is a key cause of many of the negative outcomes identified by Allen et al.Why do I see requests for additional studies as the quintessence of developmental reviewing?Asking for an additional study undermines author expertise.It not only tells authors how they should have done their current work but also how to structure their improvement effort, with the reviewer acting as mentor and study designer.Focusing on the additional study also draws attention from the accuracy and validity of the original submission.Rather than evaluating the submission on its merits, the reviewer-directed additional study is seen as a path for overcoming weaknesses in the initial design, sample, measurement, and analysis.Additional studies create a seemingly endless cycle that increases reviewer burden, as each resubmission with new data and analyses essentially starts the review process over. The prevalence of multiple studiesHow prevalent is the practice of asking for additional studies?Although we don't know if original submissions included multiple studies, we do get some sense of prevalence by examining how many published articles include more than one study.By comparing data to the timeline of developmental reviewing, using some of the same time periods adopted by Allen et al., we see a striking pattern emerge.In 2003, only 17% of the empirical articles (removing meta-analyses and scale development studies) published in the six volumes of Journal of Applied Psychology included more than one study.By the final six volumes of 2024, that figure had jumped to 86%.Given that articles including more studies are likely longer, we can also gain insight by assessing article length.The six volumes of Journal of Applied Psychology published in 2003 contained 91 studies with an average length of approximately 12 pages, whereas the final six 2024 volumes had only 50 articles with an average length of almost 21 pages.Similar patterns are evident in other journals like Personnel Psychology, Academy of Management Journal, and Journal of Management.Although I was an author, reviewer, and action editor during these years, I feel like the proverbial frog in the slowly warming pot.The process of conducting and disseminating research has substantially changed, something I didn't fully grasp before seeing the data.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Psychology Research and Bibliometrics
Academic Writing and Publishing
Publishing and Scholarly Communication
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Industrial and Organizational Psychology
- Volume
- 19
- Issue
- 1
- Pages
- 29–31
- Publication date
- 1 March 2026
- Language
- EN