From culture blind to culturally informed: Coverage of sociocultural identities in U.S.-based forensic psychology journals, 2016–2020.

View at publisher
Authors: Amanda M. Fanniff, Leila N. Wallach, Taylor York, Reilly E. Gallin, Morgan Hester Howell, Annika I. Arango
Cited by: 1

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to assess the degree to and manner in which research published in four forensic psychology journals in the years 2016-2020 addressed sociocultural identities. HYPOTHESES: This was an exploratory content analysis with no a priori hypotheses. METHOD: = 401). RESULTS: Sociocultural identities were infrequently mentioned in titles and abstracts of these articles; for example, gender was mentioned in 31.5% abstracts, and race was mentioned in 13.2%. Almost all corresponding and first authors (97.4%) worked in a United Nations regional group that includes primarily high-income, democratic nations, many of which have predominantly White populations. Gender (95%), race and/or ethnicity (74%), and socioeconomic status (43%) were the identities most frequently reported in the articles; others were very rarely reported (e.g., sexual orientation, 2%). Few studies addressed cultural strengths and/or explicitly recognized the impact of systems-level biases. Few studies explicitly addressed within-group differences for any sociocultural identity group. There was minimal evidence of improvement in the inclusion of sociocultural identities over time. CONCLUSIONS: The articles in this content analysis were largely completed prior to the publication of updated guidance regarding addressing the sociocultural identities of participants in publications. The results indicate that despite progress since previous content analyses were published, there was considerable room for improvement as of 2020. Greater attention to sociocultural factors will facilitate our understanding of the generalizability of our research and of the experiences of people with nondominant identities. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2026 APA, all rights reserved).

Fields of Study & Subjects

Counseling Practices and Supervision Cultural Differences and Values Racial and Ethnic Identity Research

Publication details

Journal / source
Law and Human Behavior
Publisher
American Psychological Association (APA)
Volume
50
Issue
4
Pages
400–420
Publication date
27 April 2026
Language
EN