What is Heterodox Economics? A Comment on Hodgson and his Critics
Abstract
This article critically analyzes Geoffrey Hodgson’s definition of heterodox economics as the refutation of the orthodox view that emphasizes utility maximization as its main theoretical core, and his view that it is the fragmentation of heterodox economics that explains its subsidiary role within the profession. Hodgson’s views led to a series of responses that criticize his definition, but also present significant problems of their own. The limitations of Hodgson and his critics’ views are contrasted with an alternative definition that emphasizes the importance of conflictive distribution and the principle of effective demand in the long run. The idea of a broad tent, from a sociological point of view, does not preclude the need for a clear analytical definition of heterodoxy. The broad tent should be seen as part of a strategy of survival.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Economic Theory and Institutions
Political Economy and Marxism
Critical Realism in Sociology
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Journal of Economic Issues
- Publisher
- Informa UK Limited
- Volume
- 60
- Issue
- 1
- Pages
- 307–314
- Publication date
- 2 January 2026
- Language
- EN