Could policy sequencing increase public support for ambitious climate policies? Experimental insights from efforts to enhance battery electric vehicle adoption in Norway and Switzerland

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Thomas Bernauer, Sverker C. Jagers, Steffen Kallbekken, Marina Povitkina, Maja Schoch
Cited by: 0
References: 70

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Conventional wisdom presumes there is a trade-off between policy effectiveness and feasibility: push policies that disincentivize undesirable behaviour and tend to be more effective are often less popular; pull policies that incentivize desired behaviour and tend to be less effective are often more popular. We link this presumption to recent research on policy sequencing to hypothesize that temporal policy sequencing, starting with pull and subsequently moving to push policies, could help achieve higher levels of public acceptance and thus mitigate the effectiveness-feasibility dilemma. We also hypothesize, however, that such an effect likely depends on how effective initial pull measures are perceived to be. We assess these arguments with an empirical focus on how to accelerate the adoption of battery electric vehicles (BEV), a key technology in decarbonising transport. To estimate potential effects of policy sequencing, we use data from original surveys in Norway (N = 1700) and Switzerland (N = 1900). Norway has had pull policies in place for several years and has achieved high levels of BEV adoption. Switzerland has no substantive pull policies in place and has a low share of BEVs. The survey includes an information provision experiment where we randomly prime respondents for pre-existing pull policies and treat them with differing effectiveness information on pull policies before eliciting support for push policies. Contrary to our expectations, we find that support for (stricter) push policies is largely unaffected by the informational treatments and does not differ across country contexts. This suggests that introducing pull policies first is, per se, unlikely to increase support for push policies at a later stage. The main policy implication is that governments should be cautious in relying on sequencing alone as a strategy to increase public support, and may benefit from exploring contemporaneous bundling of pull and push measures.Key policy insightsPublic support for stricter policies might be enhanced by policy-sequencing, starting with less strict pull policies and then shifting to push policies.Policies to accelerate the adoption of battery electric vehicles are an interesting candidate for policy sequencing.Survey experimental evidence from Norway and Switzerland does not support the policy-sequencing hypothesis.Governments may need to reconsider policy sequencing as a strategy and also explore contemporaneous bundling of pull and push measures to achieve sufficient public support levels.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Climate Change Policy and Economics Energy Environment and Transportation Policies Electric Vehicles and Infrastructure

Publication details

Journal / source
Climate Policy
Pages
1–16
Publication date
30 March 2026
Language
EN