“How Do I Navigate Those Spaces?”: A Descriptive Qualitative Study of Equity-Focused Principal Preparation for Normative and Political Resistance

View at publisher
Authors: Cassandra F. Rubinstein, Jennifer Baucom Ayscue, Mary Kathryn Oyaga, Rachel E. Rana, Zainab Abdul-Qaabidh
Cited by: 1
References: 33

Abstract

School leaders face increasing political pressures when advancing equity initiatives. This study examines how one principal preparation program prepared graduates to navigate the zone of mediation where reforms encounter resistance. Drawing on interviews with graduates and faculty, we found the program effectively equipped leaders for first-order (technical) and second-order (cultural) changes through skill-building and relational resources. However, graduates encountered significant challenges when equity work required third-order change that threatened normative beliefs and power structures. Political navigation for third-order change is situated within specific local contexts and requires both enhanced pre-service training and ongoing, contextualized support responding to unique political dynamics.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Teacher Education and Leadership Studies Educational Philosophies and Pedagogies Global Education and Multiculturalism

Publication details

Journal / source
Leadership and Policy in Schools
Publisher
Informa UK Limited
Pages
1–21
Publication date
16 February 2026
Language
EN