Too much Bible? Insights on the relationship of Scripture with non-biblical sources in practical theology through the lens of Seventh-day Adventism

The relationship between Scripture and non-biblical sources in practical theology remains the topic of considerable debate. In more conservative evangelical churches, the desire to demonstrate beliefs and practices are founded on Scripture can see them being reluctant to incorporate non-biblical sources. Using Seventh-day Adventism as a case study, this paper explores how a denomination has wrestled with the tension between maintaining faithfulness to Scripture and engaging in practical theology. While this paper contributes towards the conversation Adventism is having regarding its hermeneutics, more broadly it examines approaches to theological reflection and sources of Divine revelation, particularly attending to the task of discerning God’s ongoing activity. Through examining Adventism’s employment of the Wesleyan Quadrilateral and exploring its potential use of Theological Action Research, I offer a contrast between these two reflective practices. Ultimately, I arrive at a broader conception of what it is to engage in hermeneutics, one that is not just focused on the past but also the present, one that is Spirit-led and more open to God’s ongoing revelation.