Performing Magnetism and the Ambiguity of Play: Prudence Bernard’s ‘Artistic Oneiromancy’

View at publisher Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Kürt Vanhoutte
Cited by: 0
References: 15

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

This article delves into the mesmerising performances of Prudence Bernard, a somnambulist and mesmeric performer whose theatrical career epitomised the fusion of science, mysticism, and theatre in 19th-century Europe. It aims to highlight the key role of performativity in understanding the persistence of occult beliefs. Prudence’s acts, which ranged from trance-induced clairvoyance to dramatic historical reenactments, blurred the boundaries between reality and illusion, challenging established ideas about knowledge and engaging audiences in a complex interplay of belief and scepticism. Influenced by Franz Anton Mesmer’s theories of animal magnetism, her performances spanned a wide array of venues, from academic lecture halls to bustling fairgrounds. This study focuses on oneiromancy artistique, a theatrical show performed across Western Europe by Prudence and her magnetisers, Mr. Bernard and Auguste Lassaigne, respectively. By recontextualizing this trajectory within the confines of theatrical imagination, pivotal phases will be analysed such as the blending of acting and trance states, prompting inquiries about theatrical genre and acting conventions, and the dissolution of the boundary between belief and make-believe through live interaction on stage with the audience. The most astute spectator in the theatre was the scientist. A regular feature of Prudence’s show was the presence on stage of learned men, who manipulated the conditions of the act to test its veracity. Another important player was the magician: the expertise of the professional illusion-maker placed prestidigitators at a critical border between what they saw as their own brand of scientific entertainment and the pleasure of deception. Central to Prudence’s performances was the role of doubt—stoked by her magnetiser, heightened by the audience, and amplified by the media. Spectators didn’t attend her shows seeking definitive answers; instead, they embraced the ambiguity of whether her feats were supernatural marvels, brilliant illusions, or groundbreaking revelations of natural laws. This deliberate uncertainty allowed audiences to oscillate between belief and scepticism, mirroring the duality of Prudence herself as both a somnambulist and a performer. Ultimately, her acts showcase the transformative potential of performance, creating spaces for collective engagement with the ineffable, marked by doubt, wonder, and the ambiguous interplay of reality and illusion.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Religious Studies and Spiritual Practices Theatre and Performance Studies Theater Performance and Music History

Publication details

Journal / source
Advances in Nineteenth-Century Research
Volume
1
Issue
1
Pages
79–94
Publication date
2 January 2026
Language
EN