Carolyn Day. Remembering Anne Beach: Love, Scandal, and Sickness in Eighteenth-Century Britain .

View at publisher Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Jennifer Evans
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Carolyn Day’s Remembering Anne Beach centers on the manuscript “A NARRATIVE, Exemplifying the Cruelty of Mr and Mrs. B- -CH … A Tale of domestic and uncommon Parental Barbarity.” Penned by William Wainhouse, this narrative recounts his courtship, elopement attempts, and brief marriage to Anne Beach, before her untimely death from consumption. As Day explains, the document was intended to blame Anne’s illness and subsequent death on her parents’ cruel disapproval of their match and on their having confined Anne to a cold room in her natal home to try and prevent the marriage. From this scandalous story, Day has expertly woven together personal correspondence, receipts, the narrative itself, and printed medical literature to create a compelling and engrossing thick description of the complicated family. The book is a microhistory offering insights into experiences of schooling, physical and mental illness, networking and patronage, and family dynamics. The book very effectively sets individual experiences against the broader national context. For example, Day explores the Anglican minister Richard Wainhouse’s antagonistic relationship with two local men he described as “disaffected persons” (42). The responses of these men to Wainhouse’s anti-Catholic sermons illustrate how rising anti-Catholic sentiments during the Jacobite uprisings manifested in local tensions and concerns that those nearby might be engaged in treasonous acts. The tussle between Richard and his antagonists also reveals the methods of resistance available to ordinary parishioners; they posted a “silly paper” (42) to the east end of the church that depicted the reverend as a figure with horns and shepherd’s crook. Similarly, Day explicates William Beach of Netheravon’s interest in smallpox inoculation within broader discussions about the advocacy of the procedure by Mary Wortley Montagu and Caroline of Ansbach. Beach’s son was eventually inoculated by the pioneering practitioner Daniel Sutton, at considerable expense. Day also pieces together the story of Anne’s brother Billy, who succumbed to mental illness. Existing historical scholarship on this topic has illustrated how medical approaches to such conditions were shifting in the eighteenth century. The fragmentary evidence, pulled together into a clear life story, provides a useful example of how families understood and coped with mental illness at this time of change.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Biographical and Historical Analysis Autobiographical and Biographical Writing History of Emotions Research

Publication details

Journal / source
The American Historical Review
Volume
131
Issue
1
Pages
420–421
Publication date
7 January 2026
Language
EN