Efficacy of insecticides against soybean aphid, 2024
Summary
No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.
Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.Abstract
The efficacy of selected insecticides on naturally occurring Soybean aphid (SBA) infesting soybean was evaluated at the North Dakota State University main station agronomy farm in Fargo (Cass County). Selected insecticides included those with pyrethroids as the only AI (Asana XL, Brigade 2EC, Warrior II, Baythroid XL, and Hero), premixes of pyrethroids and aphid-specific AIs (Ridgeback, Endigo ZCX, and Renestra), and insecticides with only aphid-specific AIs (Transform 50WG, Sefina Inscalis, and Sivanto Prime) (Table 1). All tested insecticides are registered for use in soybeans in North Dakota. Means within a column that share the same letter are not significantly different (P < 0.05, Tukey’s HSD). Means within a column that share the same letter are not significantly different (P < 0.05, Tukey’s HSD). The experiment was arranged in a randomized complete block design with 4 replications (blocks). The soybean variety ‘Pioneer P06Z90E’ (maturity group 0.6) was seeded on 21 June at a rate of 140,000 seeds per acre with 20-inch row spacing. Each treatment plot was 20 ft long and 3 rows (5 ft) wide. Treatment plots within each replication were separated by an untreated ‘guard’ plot of the same dimensions as the treatment plots. This was done to mitigate spray drift between treated plots and to provide an untreated reservoir of SBA that could potentially reinfest treated plots, and, as such, potentially served as a measure of insecticide residual activity. Replications were separated by 5 ft wide alleys that were tilled throughout the course of the experiment. Soybean aphid count data were collected by counting and recording the number of SBA on five randomly selected plants per treatment plot, and calculating the average number of SBA per plant. Counts were made on 31 Jul (pre-spray (0 days after treatment [DAT], crop stage R2), 5 Aug (4 DAT, crop stage R2), 9 Aug (8 DAT, crop stage R3), 13 Aug (12 DAT, crop stage R3) and 20 Aug (19 DAT, crop stage R4). Insecticides were applied on 1 Aug after pre-spray counts on 31 July indicated that all treatments had reached or exceeded the economic threshold of 250 SBA per plant (Table 1). Insecticides were applied using a CO2-powered backpack sprayer and hand boom with TeeJet AIXR11015 nozzles at 40 psi and a delivery volume of 20 gal per acre. Environmental conditions were excellent at the time of application. Treatment plots were harvested on 3 Oct using a Wintersteiger NurseryMaster Elite plot combine. Whole plot grain samples were weighed to the nearest gram using an Ohaus Navigator laboratory balance, and grain moisture and test weight were measured using a Dickey-John GAC2500 grain computer. Plot weights were adjusted to 13% grain moisture, and grain yield was calculated using a standard test weight of 60 lbs per bu. All data were analyzed using the GLIMMIX procedure in SAS (version 9.4) statistical Software. SBA count data were subjected to ANOVA using the Poisson distribution and yield data using the normal distribution, with treatment as a fixed effect and replication (block) as a random effect. Treatment means were separated using Tukey’s HSD (α = 0.05) only when the F-test for a variable was significant (P < 0.05). There were no significant differences among treatment means for SBA per plant for the pre-spray (0 DAT) count (Table 1), indicating that SBA were relatively evenly distributed across the experiment. At 4 DAT, all stand-alone pyrethroid treatment means for SBA per plant were not significantly different from the untreated check (Table 1). The untreated check had a significantly greater mean SBA per plant than all premix and aphid-specific insecticides. While there were significant differences in mean SBA per plant between premix and aphid-specific insecticides, these differences are not economically meaningful, as these treatments exhibited mean SBA per plant well below the economic threshold. At 8 DAT, the same pattern among treatment means for SBA per plant was observed, although the untreated check had a greater mean SBA per plant than the stand-alone pyrethroids Baythroid XL and Hero (Table 1). Mean SBA per plant among the premixes and aphid-specific insecticides ranged from 1.2 (Endigo ZCX) to 18.4 (Sefina Inscalis), which were again well below the economic threshold. At 12 DAT, all stand-alone pyrethroids had treatment means for SBA per plant that were not significantly different from the untreated check, but were significantly greater than all premixes and aphid-specific insecticides (Table 1). There were no significant differences between premixes and aphid-specific insecticides for mean SBA per plant, with means ranging from 6.5 (Sivanto Prime) to 33.2 (Ridgeback) (Table 1). The same pattern was observed at 19 DAT, where the stand-alone pyrethroids were not significantly different from the untreated check, but had significantly higher mean SBA per plant than premixes and aphid-specific insecticides. Among premixes and aphid-specific insecticides, Ridgeback had a higher mean SBA per plant than Transform and Sefina, but, as with the other treatments, the means were well below the economic threshold (Table 1). All premixes and aphid-specific insecticides had significantly higher means for grain yield than the untreated check and all stand-alone pyrethroids, and there were no significant differences among premixes and aphid-specific insecticides for mean grain yield (Table 1). Among stand-alone pyrethroids, Asana XL and Baythroid XL had mean grain yields significantly higher than the untreated check. This research was funded through a grant from the North Dakota Soybean Council and through industry gifts-in-kind to support insecticide research. The authors have no conflicts of interest.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Insect-Plant Interactions and Control
Hemiptera Insect Studies
Insect Pest Control Strategies
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Arthropod management tests
- Volume
- 51
- Issue
- 1
- Publication date
- 7 January 2026
- Language
- EN