SRS122 - Time stratified outcomes of meniscal replacement: a systematic review and meta-analysis

View at publisher Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Ankur Singh, Caitlin Howey, Hamza M Umar, Romir Patel, Jamaal Choudhry, Austin R Gomindes, Henry Searle, Ian Douglas McDermott
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Abstract Background Prior evidence comparing meniscal allograft transplantation (MAT) and meniscal scaffold implantation (MSI) is limited by variable follow-up, with patient-reported-outcome-measures (PROMs) pooled across disparate time points. We addressed this with time-stratified outcome pooling. Methods We searched MEDLINE, Embase, and Web of Science Core Collection to 25 April 2025; PROSPERO registration CRD42024536408. Adults undergoing MAT or MSI (≥10 participants; >2-year follow-up) were eligible. Random-effects meta-analyses pooled PROMs at 0–2, 2–5, and >5 years; survival, return-to-sport (RTS), and complications were summarised descriptively. Risk of bias was assessed using Modified Coleman Methodology Score (MCMS). Results Eighty-one studies (MAT 59, n = 4292; MSI 22, n = 1009) were included. Overall study quality was fair-to-poor (MCMS 58.8 ± 11.1). PROMs improved after both. MAT maintained gains beyond five years (IKDC 73.1 at 2–5 years; 71.1 > 5 years), whereas MSI peaked at 2–5 years then declined (IKDC 72.5; 67.6 > 5 years); Tegner scores mirrored this pattern. Heterogeneity was considerable (27/29 analyses I² > 50% and 24/29 I² > 75%). Failure proportions were similar (MAT 18.6%; MSI 19.6%), but time to failure was longer after MAT (5.9 versus 3.1 years). Survival at fixed time points was comparable (∼90% at 5 years; ∼77% at 10 years). RTS was similar (∼65% return by 1 year; ∼50% to pre-injury level). Complications differed; further intervention was more commonly undertaken post-MAT. Conclusions Accounting for follow-up duration, MAT sustains functional gains beyond five years and shows greater durability than MSI. Prospective comparative studies with standardised failure definitions are needed to refine patient selection and expectations.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Knee injuries and reconstruction techniques Periodontal Regeneration and Treatments Elbow and Forearm Trauma Treatment

Publication details

Journal / source
British journal of surgery
Volume
113
Issue
Supplement_2
Publication date
1 March 2026
Language
EN