Jewish Men and the Holocaust: Sexuality, Emotions, Masculinity. An Intimate History . By Florian Zabransky

View at publisher Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Paul O’Shea
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Much of the historiography on the role of gender in the Holocaust has been focused on female victims or male perpetrators. Relatively few studies have sought to shed light on the gendered experiences of male victims. In Jewish Men and the Holocaust: Sexuality, Emotions, Masculinity, Florian Zabransky contributes to filling this gap in the research literature while ‘highlighting power struggles, negotiations of relationships, social dynamics and representations of masculinities’ (p. 2). The book has a coherent structure along geographical, chronological and historiographical lines. Zabransky divides his four chapters between three time frames. In keeping with the argument that gendered experience was situational and heavily affected by the spaces in which events played out, this structure works well, as the effects of geography and time frame are both emphasized as factors influencing the actors in the study. Chapter 1 is set in the years of ‘persecution’ of Jewish men in 1930s Germany. This section is primarily concerned with life in the ghettos. Zabransky argues that the ghettos were heterosexual spaces ‘in which family life, marriage and intimate encounters continued’, which ‘not only provided comfort to ghetto dwellers but reproduced a gender order favouring men’ (p. 20). Zabransky draws attention to the sexual humiliation of Jewish men by the Nazis. While the sexual abuse and humiliation of women has received much attention, the same is not true of male victims. It is a worthy and important subject, and Zabransky tactfully and respectfully analyses it alongside the likely effects on husbands, fathers and sons of sexual violence against women (pp. 32–3). Chapters 2 and 3 cover the years of ‘annihilation’, 1939 to 1945. The former chapter focuses on the experiences of Jewish men in the Nazi concentration camps. Perhaps the strongest contribution in this chapter is the analysis of ‘Piepel’ relations. These men often bartered sexual favours in return for material aid. Zabransky explores sensitive subjects such as the boundaries between male sexual barter and rape in the camps with great sensitivity and skill. The third chapter deals with the subject of partisan resistance organizations operating in forests, primarily in the Soviet Union. These forests were ‘still a male dominated space’ in which Jewish men were able to ‘reify patriarchal structures, in which men cared for the women’ (p. 21). In doing so, ­Zabransky argues, male Jewish partisans were able to reclaim a perception of themselves based on ‘an idealised image of military masculinity’ (p. 97). By engaging seriously with the narrative choices of male survivors, Zabransky is able to extract insights into their motivations and gendered behaviours. Chapter 4 covers the period of ‘liberation’, and addresses the actions of male Jewish survivors between 1945 and 1948. Zabransky argues that through work, sport and Zionism, Jewish survivors were able to rebuild their masculine identities after the devastation of the Holocaust (p. 155). The attention paid to the postwar period is a welcome addition to the study, which calls attention to the long-term consequences of the Holocaust, for Jews in Europe and beyond, after 1945.

Fields of Study & Subjects

European history and politics Gender and Feminist Studies Memory Trauma and Commemoration

Publication details

Journal / source
German History
Volume
44
Issue
2
Pages
370–372
Publication date
25 March 2026
Language
EN