Application of Six Sigma, Quality Goal Index, Method Decision Chart, and Operating Specification Metrics as Stringent Quality Control Tools for Assessing the Analytical Performance of BUN, Creatinine, and Glucose in an ISO 15189:2022–Accredited Laboratory

Read full text
Authors: Maisoon Amarni, Kamal Dumaidi, Sara Abbadi, Nataly Fakhouri, Amer Al-Jawabreh
Cited by: 3
References: 19

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Reliable analytical performance is vital for accurate diagnosis in clinical chemistry laboratories. Quality control (QC) strategies must be customized to assess performance, meet regulatory standards, and optimize resource use. This study evaluated the analytical performance of 3 routine analytes, blood-urea nitrogen (BUN), creatinine, and glucose using Sigma metrics, visualized through the Method Decision Chart (MDC), Quality Goal Index (QGI), and Operating Specifications (OPSpecs) charts, to recommend appropriate internal quality control (IQC) procedures at 3 levels (L1, L2, L3). METHODS: A 6-month retrospective analysis (June-November 2024) was performed in an ISO 15189:2022 accredited primary health care laboratory in Jenin District, Palestine. Internal QC and External Quality Assessment Scheme data were used to calculate the coefficient of variation (%CV), %bias, and Sigma values across all IQC levels, applying CLIA total allowable error limits. For analytes with Sigma 6), allowing a simplified IQC protocol (1-3.5s, N3, R1). Creatinine showed moderate performance (σ = 3.1-13.6) requiring multirule application (2 of 3-2s, R4s) at Level 2. BUN displayed poor Sigma values (σ < 4), with QGI analysis indicating alternating imprecision and inaccuracy; OPSpecs recommended full multirule implementation and root-cause investigation. CONCLUSION: The combined use of Sigma metrics, QGI, MDC, and OPSpecs charts offers an effective, risk-based QC framework enabling early detection, continuous monitoring, and timely correction of analytical errors in ISO 15189-certified laboratories.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Clinical Laboratory Practices and Quality Control Pesticide Residue Analysis and Safety Analytical Methods in Pharmaceuticals

Publication details

Journal / source
The Journal of Applied Laboratory Medicine
Publisher
Oxford University Press (OUP)
Volume
11
Issue
4
Pages
822–831
Publication date
17 March 2026
Language
EN