Letter to the Editor on “Navigating virility: penile enhancement and the evolving landscape of masculinity”

View at publisher Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Nguyễn Cao Thắng, Emmanuele Angelo Jannini
Cited by: 0
References: 4

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

The article “Navigating virility: penile enhancement and the evolving landscape of masculinity” addresses timely concerns about male body image and cosmetic genital procedures, linking it to broader sociocultural transformations.1 They argue that as Vietnam modernizes, becoming a pivotal player of globalization, traditional masculine ideals are challenged and men increasingly equate physical attributes with self-worth. The article makes an important remark by bridging cultural anthropology and public health, highlighting how cultural ideals of masculinity are not simply symbolic but can materialize in concrete medical choices. Although very interesting, we found some limitations that the JSM’s reader may find important for a critical evaluation of the piece. Overall, its scope appears narrow and largely speculative: no new empirical study is conducted, and it relies on anecdotes and secondary reports. The authors situate penile augmentation within Vietnam’s traditional Confucian patriarchy. In this view, men’s social values have long been tied to virility and family honor. However, since the (Renovation) reforms, rapid social change and women increased economic participation have put new pressures on these norms. Contemporary Vietnamese masculinity places greater emphasis on strength, competence, etiquette, and responsibility to family and community, with growing attention to equality and individual diversity. This shift is reflected in surveys showing that women’s expectations for romantic and sexual satisfaction prioritize non-physical qualities over physical traits.2 Qualities such as trust, supportiveness, and the ability to provide security rank highly in local surveys. Even in a broader cross-cultural context, researchers have found that women place greater emphasis on a partner’s socio-economic status and character when choosing a mate. When it comes to sexual satisfaction specifically, multiple studies refute the popular notion that “bigger is better” for women’s pleasure. The majority of women indicate sexual satisfaction irrespective of their partner’s genital size, emphasizing that penile dimensions are not a principal determinant of sexual pleasure. A large survey of over 50 000 people found 84% of women were satisfied with their partner’s size, with only 14% wishing larger penile size. Most women in that study ranked size as relatively unimportant compared to factors like emotional connection or foreplay.3 The preferred penis size for a long-term partner is only slightly above average and within a pretty narrow range and extremes were not desired.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Gender Roles and Identity Studies Sexual function and dysfunction studies Body Image and Dysmorphia Studies

Publication details

Journal / source
The Journal of Sexual Medicine
Volume
23
Issue
4
Publication date
9 March 2026
Language
EN