Quantifying Center-level Aggressiveness in Transplanting Suboptimal, Deceased Donor Kidneys in the United States

Background: Understanding center-level decision-making for suboptimal kidney (SOK) offers is critical to ensure utilization of all transplantable kidneys. Methods: We quantified center-level variation in accepting SOK deceased donor kidney transplant (DDKT) offers using 2021-2023 national registry data. SOK subtypes included: donor age >60, ultimate cold ischemia time >24 h, hepatitis C positive, terminal serum creatinine >2.0 mg/dL, donation after circulatory death, kidney donor profile index >85%, and public health service increased risk donors. Gini coefficient (Gini) was used to analyze inequality in DDKT utilization by SOK subtype. Multilevel logistic regression models were used to calculate the median odds ratio (mOR), measuring center-level variation in accepting SOK donor offers among adult centers. Results: Of all DDKTs, 72.6% were from donors with at least 1 SOK characteristic. Inequality persisted in utilization of SOK DDKTs (Gini of all SOKs: 0.53, Gini of all non-SOKs: 0.47). The 193 adult centers accepted a median (interquartile range) of 12.5% (8.4%-19.2%) offered non-SOK donors and 7.2% (4.6%-10.8%) offered SOK donors. Non-SOK donors and SOK donors were refused by a median (interquartile range) of 5 (3-10) and 9 (4-23) centers, respectively. The SOK subtypes with the least and the most center-level variance in acceptance were increased risk donor (mOR = 2.06) and cold ischemia time >36 h (mOR = 4.86), respectively. Conclusions: Centers vary sharply in their willingness to accept certain types of SOK offers. Informing centers of their patterns of accepting specific donor phenotypes compared with their peers may motivate centers to accept more SOKs for clinically suitable recipients, thus improving patient access to DDKT.