“Yet the Problem Remains”: Why Genetic Determinism Still Haunts Biomedical Research

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Christopher Donohue, Ian Antheni Myles
Cited by: 0
References: 80

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

After the horrors of the Holocaust and its connections to eugenics were revealed to the world, many post-war population geneticists sought to establish rhetorical distance from the Nazi's state-led campaigns, without abandoning their belief that actively shaping the population's genetics would produce a prosperous society. While many advancements in equity have come, well-intentioned geneticists continue to struggle to distance themselves from those weaponizing genetic data. Herein, we outline the practices which often prevent modern population genetics from ridding itself of the ghost of genetic determinism. These include the interlocking practices of: agnostically noting "genes matter" without detailing the degree or context of importance; using examples or explanations which can be ambiguously interpreted; using flawed data to assert that medical advances require genetic insights; homogenizing the environment in ways that ignore, rather than account for, deleterious exposures; insisting that populations be mathematically segregated prior to performing their analysis; then, when predictable harms arise, using lack of intent to harm as an excuse to refuse to change standard practices or to accept responsibility. Finally, discrete recommendations for improvements are presented. Unlike denouncements of overt eugenics, it is controversial to argue that those working on the genetics of diseases like asthma may unwittingly echo the eugenicists of the past. However, the consistency of associations between modern population genetics and historic eugenics demand mechanistic evaluation.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Race Genetics and Society Medical History and Research Ethics and bioethics in healthcare

Publication details

Journal / source
Bioethics
Volume
40
Issue
7
Pages
658–666
Publication date
22 March 2026
Language
EN