Measuring Frame Evolution: Smoothed Temporal Framing Trajectories in Complex Policy Debates

Read full text
Authors: Philip Leifeld, Kristijan Garic
Cited by: 3
References: 40

Abstract

Abstract The European Union faces long‐term governance challenges in contested domains, such as migration management, health data sharing, and facial recognition technology. Across these fields, political debates are shaped by shifting ways in which actors frame problems and solutions. Understanding how such framing contests evolve over time is crucial for explaining both integration dynamics and the capacity of EU institutions to govern effectively. This article develops the mathematical foundations of a comparative approach to frame evolution by extending discourse network analysis, acknowledging the relational nature of collective action framing. Partitioning trajectories into distinct states and phases reveals key types of frame evolution: progressive versus regressive, entangled versus disentangled, and fast‐paced versus slow. This typology provides a basis for linking framing dynamics to EU integration and policymaking processes. The article makes three contributions: operationalising collective framing trajectories; introducing a temporal kernel smoothing approach; and identifying comparative dimensions across policy debates.

Fields of Study & Subjects

European Union Policy and Governance Global Security and Public Health Qualitative Comparative Analysis Research

Publication details

Journal / source
JCMS Journal of Common Market Studies
Publisher
Wiley
Volume
64
Issue
5
Pages
1688–1714
Publication date
27 May 2026
Language
EN