Increasing Efficiency of Detection and Validation of Baleen Whale Call Presence on Large Acoustic Datasets: A Case Study Using Sei Whale Downsweeps Recorded in Atlantic Canada

Read full text
Authors: Gabrielle F. Macklin, Hilary B Moors-Murphy, Marty L. Leonard
Cited by: 0
References: 16

Abstract

ABSTRACT As passive acoustic monitoring (PAM) datasets expand, studies increasingly use automated detectors to analyze baleen whale presence. However, detector errors like false positives (impacting precision, P; proportion of detected calls that are correct), and false negatives (impacting recall, R; proportion of available calls successfully detected) necessitate manual validation. Here, we demonstrate a tiered detection and validation approach to improve efficiency in sei whale ( Balaenoptera borealis ) call presence analysis that aims to maximize R while removing false positives. Using two detectors on eastern Canadian datasets, we tested multiple parameter settings, selecting one tier that captured only high‐quality calls (High‐P), one tier that captured most calls present but included more false positives (High‐R), and one tier that balanced the P and R values (Mid). To assess daily call presence, validation proceeded sequentially across tiers from High‐P to Mid to High‐R. For each subsequent tier, detections were only reviewed from days in which sei whale calls had not yet been confirmed. For both detectors, using this tiered approach reduced the overall manual validation effort (number of detections reviewed) when compared to validating the highest recall original outputs alone. This efficient strategy maintains accuracy in PAM studies and could be used for other species.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Marine animal studies overview Animal Vocal Communication and Behavior Underwater Acoustics Research

Publication details

Journal / source
Marine Mammal Science
Volume
42
Issue
2
Publication date
16 February 2026
Language
EN