A Pilot Validation Study of Plant‐Based and Allergy‐Friendly Alternative for Testing Gastric Emptying: A Randomized Trial in Healthy Participants

Read full text
Authors: Kara J. Jencks, Nada Abdelnaem, Paula Carlson, Irene A. Busciglio, Duane B. Burton, Michael Ryks, Derek R. Johnson, Patrick J. Navin, Corrie R. Bach, Andrew M. Paulsen, David J. Bartlett, M. Camilleri
Cited by: 1
References: 13

Abstract

ABSTRACT Background Gastric emptying (GE) scintigraphy with 4‐h imaging and a radiolabeled chicken egg‐based meal (320 kcal, 30% fat) is the standard test for gastroparesis at Mayo Clinic, with an intraindividual coefficient of variation (COV intra ) of 23.8% for GE half emptying time (T 1/2 ). Alternative meals for patients with dietary restrictions, including egg allergies or vegan diets, are lacking, limiting test accessibility. The study aimed to establish a vegan, lactose‐, nut‐, and gluten‐free meal with similar caloric and fat content to the egg meal and to assess its performance in GE studies. Methods In Vitro: 99m Tc binding to egg meal over 4 h was compared to a calorically and nutritionally similar vegan alternative, JUST Egg, using a validated in vitro model simulating gastric conditions of pH, pepsin, and stirring. In Vivo: 10 healthy participants underwent randomized crossover GE scintigraphy with standard and vegan meals, spaced ≥ 3 days apart to measure GE% at 2 h, 4 h, and GE T 1/2 . Group comparisons and variance analysis included Rank Sum tests and Bland–Altman plots. Key Results In Vitro: A strong correlation ( R = 0.975, p ‐value < 0.01) between 99m Tc binding in the egg and vegan egg models was observed. Minimal variance (< 10%) was recorded at all time points. In Vivo: GE at 4 h and GE T 1/2 showed non‐statistically significant mean differences, < 2% and < 10 min respectively, between both meals. The intra‐individual variability was 18.8%. Conclusions and Inferences The vegan meal demonstrated in vitro stability, in vivo performance comparable to the egg meal, and a COV intra of 18.8%, which was lower than the 23.8% reported in repeat egg meal GE studies. Trial Registration ClinicalTrials.gov number NCT06991036 ( https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT06991036?term=NCT06991036&rank=1 )

Fields of Study & Subjects

Gastrointestinal motility and disorders Inflammatory Bowel Disease Celiac Disease Research and Management

Publication details

Journal / source
Neurogastroenterology & Motility
Publisher
Wiley
Volume
38
Issue
2
Pages
e70268–e70268
Publication date
1 February 2026
Language
EN