PPF29 Assisted dying in frailty: scoping literature review

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Katy Hyams, Annabel C. Price, Sarah Hopkins, Christina Luk, Tommaso Squeri, Isla L. Kuhn, Nick Carter, Simon Noah Etkind
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Background Frailty is an increasingly common end-of-life trajectory, therefore is highly relevant to Assisted Dying (AD) practice and debate. The extent of evidence on AD in frailty is unknown; we reviewed available literature to explore what is known and identify evidence gaps. Method Scoping literature review: search strategy developed with a medical librarian using terms relevant to ‘frailty’ and ‘assisted dying’. 5 databases were searched without limits on date or language, plus hand-searching of reference lists and citations. Quality assessment using Gough’s Weight of Evidence, with narrative synthesis of findings. Results We included 22 articles from 1310 results. Studies were from Europe, the USA, Canada and Australia, both pre-and post-legislation. Frailty was variably defined. Seven studies in Canada and the Netherlands demonstrated that although AD occurs in frailty, this represents the minority of cases. In patients living with frailty requesting AD, studies described complex suffering across physical, social, psychological and existential domains. Eight studies assessed patient attitudes towards AD, but few involved in-depth qualitative analysis from patients experiencing frailty. A substantial minority of patients supported AD, although frailty was sometimes negatively associated with supportive views; few papers explored frailty as the primary reason for requests. The majority of clinicians (two studies) opposed AD in frailty-related scenarios; one study examined carer/relative views. Three studies involved some discussion of potential impacts of legislation. Patients and professionals raised concerns about vulnerable patients, coercion, capacity, and mental illness; however, discussion about safeguards was limited. Conclusions Evidence regarding assisted dying in frailty is limited, largely consisting of descriptions of usage, associations of views with demographic variables, and consideration of hypothetical scenarios. There is little information about views and experiences of frail patients or their carers; collecting such data would inform approaches to practice, especially given the progress of relevant legislation in England, Wales and Scotland.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Palliative Care and End-of-Life Issues Palliative and Oncologic Care Ethics and bioethics in healthcare

Publication details

Journal / source
BMJ Supportive & Palliative Care
Pages
A54.1–A54
Publication date
25 March 2026
Language
EN