Increasing App Engagement Behaviors via Goal-Enabling Technology Features: The Role of Goal Difficulty Dimensions

Mobile applications in the personal development sector increasingly integrate goal-enabling technology features (GETFs), which allow users to define a service-related end goal, set implementation strategies through subgoals, and monitor progress. Little is known, however, about how the difficulty of goals chosen during GETF adoption affects subsequent app behaviors. This study examines whether customers who set more versus less difficult end goals and subgoals show greater engagement and retention, and whether firms can nudge customers toward goal-difficulty levels conducive to sustained engagement. Using behavioral data from an investment app that introduced GETFs, the authors employ hierarchical modeling with staggered synthetic control and instrumental variable regression to address self-selection and endogeneity. Results reveal substantial heterogeneity: Many adopters show no or negative engagement changes, whereas those selecting moderately challenging goals and subgoals significantly increase in-app investment actions, though not sign-ins. Higher engagement postadoption predicts improved retention after one year. A field experiment confirms that subgoal difficulty causally drives in-app actions. These findings suggest that personalized guidance during GETF adoption can enhance sustained engagement. Marketing managers are advised to tailor goal-setting features to individual needs, providing expert-like support. This research provides novel empirical evidence on goal-difficulty levels that most effectively promote app engagement.