The garden of evaluation approaches: Supporting explicit, theory-informed evaluation practice

Read full text
Authors: Daniela C. Schröter, Lyssa Wilson Becho, Bianca Montrosse-Moorhead
Cited by: 2
References: 95

Abstract

This article presents an expanded Garden of Evaluation Approaches, a multidimensional framework that bridges theory and practice to strengthen evaluation in complex global contexts. The Garden now maps 13 approaches across intersecting dimensions and introduces two new elements: evaluand focus and lifecycle timing. Developed through systematic review and rubric-based analysis, it operationalises theoretical distinctions into visual profiles and evidence-based resource guides, enabling comparative learning, hybridisation, and context-sensitive design. By integrating underrepresented paradigms alongside established models, the Garden advances pluralism, equity, and methodological innovation. At the same time, it contributes to scholarly debates on classification logic and paradigm integration, offering a dynamic platform for research, pedagogy, and capacity-building. Designed as a living framework, the Garden invites co-creation and adaptation, positioning itself as both a practical decision-support tool and a catalyst for advancing evaluation theory and global practice.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Evaluation and Performance Assessment Community Health and Development Health Policy Implementation Science

Publication details

Journal / source
Evaluation
Publisher
SAGE Publications
Volume
32
Issue
2
Pages
228–258
Publication date
4 March 2026
Language
EN