Who Tells Whose Stories? Translation Dilemmas and Epistemic Injustice in Insider Research

Read full text
Authors: Saambavi Sivaji
Cited by: 1
References: 44

Abstract

In this paper, I write an analytic autoethnography of insider research from my positionality as a Sri Lankan Tamil researcher writing within and about my own community which had experienced systemic discrimination and marginalisation by the state. From an archive of memories and reflexive fieldnotes, I examine how as an insider researcher, my own narratives and those of my community are frequently rendered suspect within qualitative research and how epistemic injustice affects whose knowledge is treated as legitimate. Foregrounding translation as the central analytical lens, I focus on the dilemmas I encounter when moving between language, meanings, contexts and the ethical and epistemic tensions this movement produces. I argue that translation is entangled with experiences of silence and proximity which emerge as supporting analytical lenses for understanding the challenges of representing communities marked by structural marginalisation and trauma. Through this analysis, I conceptualise translation as a key site of epistemic negotiation in insider research and also present how silence and proximity can function as both data and analytic resources.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Qualitative Research Methods and Ethics Participatory Visual Research Methods Data Analysis and Archiving

Publication details

Journal / source
International Journal of Qualitative Methods
Publisher
SAGE Publications
Volume
25
Publication date
19 January 2026
Language
EN