Predicting the pathway involvement of metabolites annotated in the MetaCyc knowledgebase

BACKGROUND: The associations of metabolites with biochemical pathways are highly useful information for interpreting molecular datasets generated in biological and biomedical research. However, such pathway annotations are sparse in most molecular datasets, limiting their utility for pathway level interpretation. To address these shortcomings, several past publications have presented machine learning models for predicting the pathway association of small biomolecule (metabolite and xenobiotic) using data from the Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG). But other similar knowledgebases exist, for example MetaCyc, which has more compound entries and pathway definitions than KEGG. RESULTS: As a logical next step, we trained and evaluated multilayer perceptron models on compound entries and pathway annotations obtained from MetaCyc. From the models trained on this dataset, we observed a mean Matthews correlation coefficient (MCC) of 0.845 with 0.0101 standard deviation, compared to a mean MCC of 0.847 with 0.0098 standard deviation for the KEGG dataset. However, KEGG's 184 metabolic-only pathway predictions (out of 502 total pathways) have a mean MCC of 0.800 with 0.021 standard deviation. Since MetaCyc pathways are metabolic focused, the MetaCyc results represent over a 5.6% improvement in metabolic pathway prediction performance. CONCLUSIONS: These performance results are pragmatically the same, demonstrating that in aggregate, the 4055 MetaCyc pathways can be effectively predicted at the current state-of-the-art performance level.