Toward an Archival and Post-Nationalist History of Korea: A Roundtable on the Scholarly Impact of Carter Eckert

View at publisher Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Sungik Yang, Hyung Gu Lynn, Michael E. Robinson, Michael Kim, Peter Banseok Kwon, Anna Jungeun Lee, Seungsook Moon, Tae Gyun Park, André Schmid
Cited by: 0
References: 13

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Roundtable date: February 21, 2025Yang: Thank you everyone for joining us today. My name is Sungik Yang, and I am an assistant professor of history at Arizona State University. I would like to thank Hyung-Gu Lynn, the AECL/KEPCO Chair in Korean Research at the University of British Columbia, for co-organizing this event.This roundtable is being held to commemorate Carter J. Eckert, Yoon Se Young Professor of Korean History at Harvard University, who passed away on December 13, 2024. Given his stature in the field of Korean history, we thought it would be appropriate to hold this roundtable to reflect on Carter’s contributions to our knowledge of Korea’s modern past and to the field of Korean studies at large. Through this roundtable, we will explore his impact on our understandings of Korean capitalism, economic development, militarism, and modernity, both in English-language and in Korean-language scholarship, as well as the distinctiveness of his methodological approach.For this task, we’ve gathered seven scholars to discuss Carter’s intellectual legacy, whom I will introduce now. We’ll start with our lead moderator Michael Robinson, professor emeritus at Indiana University, who knew Carter since their days in the Peace Corps. Next, in alphabetical order, we have Michael Kim (professor of Korean studies at the Graduate School of International Studies, Yonsei University), Peter Banseok Kwon (associate professor of Korean studies at the University at Albany, State University of New York), Anna Jungeun Lee (assistant professor of history at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign), Seungsook Moon (professor of sociology at Vassar College), Tae Gyun Park (professor of Korean studies at the Graduate School of International Studies, Seoul National University), and Andre Schmid (professor in the Department of East Asian Studies, University of Toronto). Thank you everyone for taking the time to join us here, despite your busy schedules and different time zones.Next, I will turn the discussion over to Hyung-Gu.Lynn: In addition to reiterating my thanks to the co-organizer, the moderator, and all the participants for their time and energy, I would like to explain our rationale for inviting you to join this roundtable. Rather than simply assemble former advisees or senior scholars (by whatever criteria), we sought to reflect a diversity and range in relationships to Carter Eckert, from long-time friends to former advisees to those who might have known him at more of an arm’s length, as well as from different ages or generations, genders, and disciplines.Robinson: Thank you to the co-organizers and all the participants for joining us today. This is a great opportunity to remember Carter Eckert and examine his scholarly contributions. Without further ado, let us start with our first question: “How did Carter’s scholarship affect views of Korean capitalism and economic development?”Kwon: Before I begin, I want to express my deep gratitude for this opportunity to honor Professor Carter Eckert’s scholarship and legacy. My sincere thanks to the co-organizers, the moderator, and my co-participants in this roundtable.To fully grasp and appreciate the initial and lasting impact of Carter’s work and some of the fundamental ways it contributed to our understanding of Korean capitalism, I think we must first consider the historiographical and political climate from which his scholarship emerged. When Offspring of Empire was published in 1991, Korean historiography was still largely dominated by nationalist narratives, particularly “sprouts theory” (maengaron), or internal development theory (naejaejŏk palchŏnnon), which posited that Korea had begun modernizing independently as early as the seventeenth century, only to have Japanese colonial rule (1910–1945) thwart this progress.1 Based on this framework, Japanese rule was seen as exclusively detrimental to Korea’s development, while South Korea’s economic success in the 1960s and 1970s was portrayed as a byproduct of indigenous national capital (minjok chabon) and free of colonial influence.2Carter’s empirically rich and analytically nuanced study of the origins of Korean capitalism profoundly complicated this dominant narrative. Rather than viewing South Korea’s “economic miracle” as solely the product of indigenous efforts or external aid (as some scholars argued), his work empirically demonstrated how Japan’s colonial administration established modern industrial and financial institutions while also fostering the rise of “a native bourgeois class” of entrepreneurs, who would become essential to postwar Korea’s capitalist economy.3 He further showed how Korean agency—far from being passive—played a decisive role in shaping Korea’s economic development by engaging with and adapting to these colonial structures.Drawing from previously untapped archives of the Kyŏngsŏng Spinning & Weaving Company and extensive Japanese and Korean sources, his study of the Koch’ang Kims illustrated how Korean entrepreneurs proactively leveraged the colonial economic system. This challenged the prevailing nationalist and Marxist binary frameworks of “oppressor versus victim,” demonstrating that the development of Korean capitalism was far more complex. At the same time, by emphasizing the agency of Koreans who creatively and effectively utilized colonial structures for their own benefit, he offered a more nuanced perspective that did not completely reject the internal development theory.Furthermore, Carter’s research provided essential empirical groundwork for the theoretical discussions that led to the introduction of the concept of “colonial modernity” by Michael Robinson and Gi-Wook Shin.4 This framework highlighted the paradoxical nature of colonialism, recognizing its role in establishing critical foundations for South Korea’s capitalist growth while acknowledging its oppressive features.These patterns were reinforced in Carter’s 2016 book, Park Chung Hee and Modern Korea: The Roots of Militarism, where he extensively examined how Park’s experiences in colonized Manchuria shaped South Korea’s postwar developmental model.5 Park’s military training and exposure to Manchukuo’s economic planning provided the foundation for core features of his later leadership: centralized industrial planning, the integration of state and business, the formation of the chaebŏl system, and the militarized mobilization of labor, among others. By tracing the historical formation of militarism and capitalism within the society and in the “minds” of key figures, Carter was able to paint a clearer picture of Park Chung Hee’s developmental state in the 1960s and 1970s and its colonial antecedents.6Carter’s scholarship transcended Korean history, influencing scholars in political economy, sociology, development studies, and comparative history. His work informed debates about the origins of the East Asian developmental state. More specifically, researchers debated whether South Korea’s economic miracle was primarily a Cold War phenomenon or whether it was an extension of colonial structures. His meticulous research convincingly traced significant continuities between colonial-era economic institutions and South Korea’s postcolonial development, prompting a re-evaluation of the roles of colonialism, militarism, and capitalism in shaping economic trajectories in the entire region and beyond.Schmid: Thank you for organizing this event and inviting me to join. My connections to Carter were perhaps less close than others who are at this roundtable, having only met him three or four times in substantive ways. Nonetheless, I always appreciated his generosity in writing letters of support and, of course, knew him through his writings.Following Peter’s comprehensive historiographical analysis of Carter’s work, I want to focus on one point regarding Carter’s book, Offspring of Empire—its focus on capitalism. The book was groundbreaking in English-language literature on Korea’s colonial period. While Korean-language literature had a long tradition of analyzing Korean capitalism, there were, in relative terms, far fewer academic works in English that tackled capitalism in this period.I do see a distinction between Carter’s emphasis on capitalism and Michael Robinson and Gi-Wook Shin’s work on colonial modernity.7 Exploring these differences in this roundtable would be illuminating, in that it would re-focus attention on capitalism, especially in the colonial period.The cultural turn, while encouraging important contributions, may have shifted attention away from economic elements. While the contributions from this shift have been significant, rather than simply assuming economic we might from Carter’s of the and capitalism at the core of our analysis and their of this is that I always thought that his to capitalism to historical and to was an essential of Offspring of The on in the colonial I to be particularly I with Andre that Carter’s focus on the of capitalism is more than colonial Nonetheless, Carter’s work and the we had an deep in the impact of He the of history, whether in or the engaging in discussions about the Empire with and extensively the Japanese He had a with over of Carter’s the of Japan’s in the of and in colonial This analysis of the of the Japanese with Korean capitalism a significant to our understanding of this and its I want to that Carter’s Offspring of Empire highlighted the role of as the foundation for capitalist development, how the Koch’ang Kim leveraged their to capital and while colonial was not the focus of Carter’s first book, his work essential in understanding the Korean contributions to capital formation the colonial period. Without his our understanding of the economic of that would be the to the early scholars as for their to economic development within the colonial Carter’s work the of development by demonstrating that Korean entrepreneurs utilized colonial capital to their own This challenged the of colonial development and a more nuanced picture of Korean agency and economic the colonial to how Carter’s of his own work his book significant in did Carter’s own understanding of his scholarship over time in to this In my Carter’s perspective on Offspring of Empire He his focus on his work while also to the period. a he traced to explore the early of Park Chung the of Japanese militarism on Park’s and the of economic us on to the question: “How did Carter’s scholarship impact views on in Korea Korean Thank you for this opportunity to my I want to start by that Carter’s to be a of his in a that his Through this Carter’s work our understanding of Korean by emphasizing the historical continuities between the colonial and than viewing as a in his work Carter the and the of colonial and cultural patterns in both South and This perspective the of Korean modernity, to explain the of between and In my the of by Yoon in December Carter’s these patterns a of Korea’s modernity, well work how these that was in a centralized state with which in the of a militarized Carter’s analysis the modern Korean not as an as an for and in which was a of the and the of the in Carter’s book on Park Chung Hee is his discussion of the system, a of the military This in for economic development also the groundwork for political and Carter that the of Korea’s militarized is not an rather it was in the continuities from the colonial In this his work with that of the who the concept of “colonial in his Carter the to this both scholars the of an in shaping is not that I the scholars both the in their of Carter’s analysis is the concept of He that modern Korea not as a fully as a society where the to state This he had for the of and in South Carter that this a of the capitalist from a he in a on the South Korean to not fully in his work, this Carter’s of his time in Korea in the Carter’s scholarship on offered a through which we Korea’s By the deep historical the colonial to he our understanding of Korea’s In of his I am not that Carter Eckert’s on in Korea and understandings of was or large. In Offspring of Empire was not an by I do not to this among researchers in discussion and to a shift in the and a within the Korean historical by as a of scholars to the established nationalist This a deep in the in these the for Korean in This intellectual in by Carter’s work and the debates it contributed to a of Korea’s colonial past and its impact on economic in of Korea University an Carter in the of which is by the for Korean in to the the that with the of “colonial Carter’s research and Gi-Wook and Michael important roles in this of and the of the of Carter’s Offspring of Empire these works to a Korean Carter’s on Korean scholars in Korean is perhaps in the book by and research in historical also in Korea’s political The of the New in Korea led to to Eckert’s scholarship for political it that Carter that his research did not have political or perhaps he was of the of his He his name to a by a of the New Carter’s perspective was the of works by his of Offspring of Empire and his own book, the In the Offspring for emphasizing the of Korean entrepreneurs colonial that to be a of the in and with Carter to me his at being and by the New Carter his research and had been him to express of the and the it we turn our attention to Carter’s book on Park Chung to my the growth of the of Korea and the of 2016 book, were both by that Carter passed away of the Park Chung Hee had been and published in Korean and a of this be also that Carter’s study of Park Chung Hee not the attention it in Korean I think Carter Eckert had a on Korean society through his with that substantive and of J. on the More than I think Carter’s published which were by in as had a impact on Korean society by that not all scholars in or at Harvard the same views as turn to the question: “How did Carter’s research impact Korean scholarship on and economic history, and how have of or to it over the his research been and how this over time, especially on the political When Carter his research on colonial development, the prevailing framework for understanding economic history was the internal development in the 1960s and This with its nationalist with book, which Korean to the within the Japanese colonial historiography that Koreans as of capitalist colonial that Korea’s historical and was The analysis on internal development theory was in the as and rather than and In the internal development the that Korea’s was by which Korean scholars theory” scholars in Korea Carter’s as of the in colonial Offspring the that he was that external were dominant in shaping modern Korean Carter these in the introduction to the of his book in He that his in Korean he it as a between external and This was a perspective that transcended like Koreans or In he to examine how Koreans and utilized by external This is he Park Chung Hee did within the opportunity structures by the Japanese the at the core of Carter’s analysis the of Korean was the point that his He to how to and This is in his work to where he Koreans despite and more Korean-language scholarship on economic history a significant with Carter’s analysis of the and there is a emphasis on might be a studies that Korean capitalist development was not a or internal as and the of colonial Modern scholarship internal development with external a more nuanced of historical the scholarship the binary of colonial versus internal in Korean economic development and studies an by frameworks the significant of colonial rule on economic and while acknowledging indigenous as economic and the of in the internal development and colonial development as rather than of a historical despite we have a more perspective on Korean economic history, I thanks in to Carter’s early I would like to turn to the question: “How did Carter’s scholarship to our understanding of the role of the military in Korean Before I would like to express my gratitude to the some I first Carter Eckert in early while the Korea at Harvard as a I At the time, I was my first book and we a in the military and in I to Harvard as the professor at the for International this I a with in December his over in of his this a to my understanding of his this a opportunity to reflect on of his scholarship, particularly the of I would like to start by a of the from the of the to the of which I think more with the core focus of Carter’s I have militarism from I have always appreciated the of historical within the of the and of our Carter’s scholarship critical analysis of militarism as a a perspective by that on and of while of militarism extensive and analysis of in Korea is He effectively and the historical the of In the first the and early he the to through modern military structures. The on Japanese militarism the colonial a and studies my own work with the which Carter to in his militarism as the extension of military and the military a that and economy, and This with the by political Michael which I in my own militarism as the and that and militarism in this our understanding of the on society and the of in the name of us to examine how the of military and of society and, us to militarism as and in with economic and political own work on Korean highlighted its with militarism, particularly In studies have demonstrated that was extensive and to the of in the state as a for with been an and and political history. critical studies of militarism must more attention to this as Carter did in his I that despite its in Korea’s modern history, research on militarism and the role in Korea’s history been by and the with of Japanese military rule and This South Korea’s further the military in society and have a in the study of modern Korean militarism, its impact on labor, and a critical a historical and empirical analysis tracing the origins and rise of militarism in Korean Chung Hee and Modern Korea this on extensive Carter traced the historical development of militarism through three the introduction of modern military institutions in to to the of and institutions Japan’s colonial mobilization to and the Cold War of This demonstrated that Korean militarism Park Chung Hee’s through historical than a Carter Park Chung Hee within these historical He the concept of to how patterns shaped Park’s Through meticulous Carter through his military in Park Japan’s military as for Park’s and the integration of militarism economic development, and the of state and society a militarized of national my own In my book, I his concept of to how Park’s militarized shaped his to I as This the of and the mobilization of and through like National the National the national and and Carter’s on Park his first established key and connections between the and Park’s development of South He demonstrated how Park’s in the Japanese military the the the integration of 1960s and 1970s industrial the of the and the of the and like the New National and mobilization Japanese colonial where and structures military his scholarship for understanding how military and to the experiences of postcolonial us to the question: “How did Carter’s scholarship examine the nature and of particularly Thank you to the of this roundtable. in the in his book Park Chung Hee and Modern to militarism and also about the military within the Korean state and In his book, he at how military and military important roles in shaping some of the of in postwar South He traced the origins and development of the postwar South Korean in its to political which a by and Park Chung Hee further this a state and society in of a society with with and for state In was important to Park was national and this transcended to some which with the of his His was mobilization for economic and national through I will focus on some about military In his book, Carter highlighted the in the Japanese military which a to these institutions a which was in This was to the Korean and contributed to the of a and This with its and and cultural a to as a of as which been by the of South Korea’s on further the between and the state. to financial capitalism, industrial capitalism provided to military a was with his economic to as the The of this cultural and the rise of financial capitalism and the for with The of from the of the role as the who with the of This to over military or primarily or exclusively as a In of militarism a understanding of Korean us to the and question: there about Carter’s methodological to and writing history you might want to The been time I would also be in Carter’s intellectual have been on the impact of his work on it would be to also about those who to the I would like to a of Carter’s his to empirical history. He was a In the academic and and the between and Carter as an empirical and his of research is in the and of his meticulous work and especially for the Park Chung Hee provided rich that and challenged his nuanced of Park Chung Hee’s of a military challenged the of this as solely a of He that for the not in the Japanese in its of being or a through military a understanding of within Korean I want to the and in Carter’s which you I his and to comprehensive works of a of a of scholarship, always emphasizing the of and historical His is also in his work, particularly in their and to empirical I these Carter was a who close attention to whether through research or He from recognizing the nature of He as to his than with Carter to the it to his he in he historical with not with He the empirical it while in Carter of the always the He both the and the He appreciated both the and the recognizing the and within while a focus on the you the research I think it is to the the This be Carter’s of this his and to He this of from while at the same time encouraging to start with a empirical He over always you the I would like to to the of I first Carter at Harvard in He his book on Park Chung Hee within a it was not in I about his and framework had he the was not to his perspective on Korea in the 1960s and 1970s from the first Park Chung Hee since his focus was largely on the period. This is particularly to me I with him on a about Korea in the which to about Carter’s in or Carter to me three that had a impact on by and The of the by a emphasis on the military and and by works and their his own scholarship, particularly his on militarism and in Korean Carter also the of works in historical sociology, especially of and one of his former I would like to one regarding Carter’s Carter’s to research was He being to a for his of in archives and the I he might not have been His for empirical established a that my research and that of others. In the in with Anna we a for Carter’s The his in his we were of how of us the he Carter’s to research was in his of from the Korean National His for and to a for his and on this to research is one of Carter’s on Carter’s in these three is the are your and shaped not only his own also those of his who it to in their own In all of these one also see the of Carter’s in I may also on his In Park Chung Hee and Modern Carter to a of the While some might a focus on Park Chung Hee and militarism, Carter an of the experiences of a military in Manchuria of the to the of the Japanese This to a comprehensive of the military that be to Park’s a of the military of his book which as an for our own of the I was by Carter’s to this was a of in that it was a he it to its in shaping and historical I that Carter had to be able to research for on a Carter’s to understanding Korea was in his deep with the and its in all his He time in a of relationships and the of Korean His in the was not only for his also for his of Korean I would like to thank everyone for joining the roundtable. I think it will as a to remember Carter as a and and the of and on his contributions and his Carter was a and an to us At the same time, I think we were also able to of Carter’s and as a not as a in this I also want to express my gratitude and sincere for time and contributions to this roundtable.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Korean Peninsula Historical and Political Studies Philosophy History and Historiography Digital and Traditional Archives Management

Publication details

Journal / source
˜The œjournal of Korean studies
Volume
31
Issue
1
Pages
3–20
Publication date
1 March 2026
Language
EN