The State at a Crossroads: Legal Pluralism in Indonesia's Indigenous Peoples' Agrarian Conflicts

Read full text
Authors: Ahmad Tohirin, Eni Febrianti, Agustina Rahmawati, Rani Dian Iswari, Dimas Wicaksana, Firda Ainun Ula, Rasyiq Arif Buamona, Megarini Ivonny Sapulette, Muhammad Rifki Rosman, Kalvin Yulnex Maniani
Cited by: 0
References: 19

Abstract

One of the most difficult types of agrarian dispute to resolve in conflict-prone countries is one involving corporations, governments, and powerful individuals. Indonesia has the sixth highest agrarian conflict rate in Asia. This dispute took place in 74% of all occurrences, 94% of all individual victims, and 84% of all impacted households. This article focuses on territorial boundaries between indigenous tribes as well as Indonesian government programs such as public infrastructure development, which includes roads, bridges, airports, ports, and trains. This study combines historical analysis with current developments to contribute to an empirical and theoretical understanding of land battles. This article gives a systematic evaluation of the literature on indigenous peoples using the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic evaluation and Meta-Analysis) methodology. This review looks at three academic databases: Scopus, ScienceDirect, SpringerLink, and Eric. These findings reveal that many indigenous tribes continue to lack legal or official recognition. Despite constitutional law, Indonesia, a multicultural country, has customary and religious rules among its indigenous tribes. Recognition of customary law and customary land still lacks a solid foundation.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Land Rights and Reforms Indigenous Peoples' Rights and Law Agriculture Land Use Rural Development

Publication details

Journal / source
F1000Research
Volume
15
Pages
154–154
Publication date
30 January 2026
Language
EN