Mehanizmi književnoga vrednovanja – od akademije do bloga

View at publisher Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Terezija Šijaković Bošković
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

The dissertation analyses the mechanisms of evaluation in the Croatian contemporary literary field with the aim of proving literary texts as active participants of the process of evaluation. The research focuses on the reception of novels by Kristian Novak to explore the process of their high circulation, establish the connections among the texts and readers that have formed networks in which the novels are continuously evaluated and their potential active role in the process. The research conducted among contemporary evaluators provides semi-structural data which completes theoretical insights, data on the most borrowed literary titles from 2013 to 2018 provided by the Zagreb City Libraries, critical reception, and data on the most popular literary titles in bookstores. Drawing extensively on theoretical approaches from Pierre Bourdieu’s field theory and Rita Felski’s interpretation of Bruno Latour’s Actor Network Theory and literary texts as active agents, the research aims to reveal how literary value is produced, contested, and maintained in a network of professional and non professional readers – academics, literary critics, publishers, librarians, teachers, readers, bloggers, agents, festivals and awards, media and representative of the Ministry of Culture and Media. The doctoral dissertation is informed by mixed method research, which integrates qualitative and quantitative data, including surveys with a diverse cohort of stakeholders in the Croatian literary field, aiming to chart the emergence of new actors, the transformation of the canon, and the ongoing redefinition of literary evaluation in digital and post-transitional contexts. The paper opens with the diachronic analysis of the literary canon’s formation from antiquity to modernity. It traces early conceptualizations of canonical collections, such as those in ancient Greece, through to the institutionalization of literary canons in the 18th and 19th centuries tied to the rise of the national canon, such as the one formed in Croatia. The study situates the canon neither as a static repository of universal artistic excellence nor purely as a socio-political construct but as a dynamic site where cultural power, educational policies, and collective identities are negotiated. The formation of the literary canon is described as a complex, layered process involving ongoing consensus among critics, historians, and readers. Survey results show that contemporary evaluators see canon as either a standard of excellence or a selected list of works, characterized both by its endurance and value, but also by exclusivity and rigidity. Respondents emphasize the need to question the canon continuously to make room for new voices and challenge exclusionary practices. The canon is primarily understood as a list of the most valuable works that should be inherited by future generations. Fewer respondents see it as a reflection of the values and ideologies of dominant groups—shaped by institutional authorities but ideally confirmed by a broader range of readers. Some participants voice concerns about the canon’s lack of relevance today, seeing it as rigid, outdated, or influenced by political interests rather than contemporary literary production. There is general agreement among respondents that the canon exists in Croatian literature, but its relevance is much debated. Those who find it irrelevant cite reasons like thematic and genre exclusivity, neglect of innovation, disconnection from the current literary scene, or being tailored mainly to public preferences. Many stress the influence of institutional authorities on canon formation and argue for greater critical engagement and professional input, especially regarding new or contemporary authors. Both classic and contemporary authors are considered canonical; however, the inclusion of new works in reference literature (e.g., histories, compilations, anthologies) is seen as essential for their lasting recognition. The process should remain open and subject to revaluation, especially to incorporate marginalized voices. The chapter on the formation of the literary market and the author as an independent creator and owner traces the historical connection between literature and the market, highlighting that the emergence of professional authorship in the 18th century, supported by market expansion and copyright laws, marked a key transformation that enabled writers to become independent from patronage and directly address readers through the market. Bourdieu’s “paradoxical logic” of the literary field in contrast to the commercial field, explains how the literary field in 19th-century France established its autonomy by inverting commercial values: works that resist popular taste and commercial profitability are accorded the highest symbolic value. Artistic value is thus created through opposition to market logic, maintained by critics, peers, and expert institutions within the field. This paradox is central to understanding the way literary value and recognition operate independently of economic success and provides context for the research into the post-transitional Croatian literary field, where professional critics no longer hold an exclusive consecrating role; instead, non-professional evaluators from the digital sphere have become significant, and their activities are explored through the example of literary bloggers. A historical review of the literary market’s formation and criticism’s development continues with an analysis of data on state support for books and publishing from 2020 to 2024. This includes trends in financing and mechanisms for awarding support through public calls by the Ministry of Culture and Media. State support policies introduced to counteract economic pressures guarantee funding for all actors in the book supply chain: authors, libraries, publishers, bookstores, and professional associations through a transparent public selection process involving complex and changing evaluation criteria and judgments of different commissions that include professionals whose experience in the literary field is defined as crucial for their engagement. The steady increase in the funds over the studied period of five years provides stability, encourages diversity, and supports valuable but less market sustainable genres and authors, thereby alleviating economic pressures on the book market. The dissertation further explores the characteristics of the post-transitional Croatian literary field shaped by the post-socialist economic, cultural, political and social transition. In view of the resulting changes in evaluative roles, the analysis of contemporary evaluators also includes non-professional readers, to whom new media provide a platform for writing reviews of literary works. Research by Simone Murray and Beth Driscoll show that global trends are mirrored in the Croatian literary field – the contemporary Croatian digital sphere is likewise marked by the democratization of evaluation and the distribution of critical authority. New evaluators, active recreational readers, freely express their views and impressions of literary works and are oriented toward communication and building relationships with their reader followers. This is confirmed by the analysis of responses from literary bloggers who participated in the study on evaluation mechanisms, showing that their priority in writing about literary works is not one-way value assessment, but communication with their followers. By insisting on communication and affirmative reflections on literary titles that left the strongest impression on them, as well as on the freedom to select parts of the text without considering the literary work or literary production as a whole, literary bloggers generally do not aspire to fill the gap created by the restructuring of the literary field and the significant reduction in the number of active literary critics. Through proactive cultural policies and by securing platforms for their activity, it is necessary to support professional literary critics and revitalize their role in the contemporary Croatian literary field. The central empirical focus of the dissertation is the case study on the reception and evaluation of Kristian Novak’s novels, marking a phenomenon of contemporary literary success. Novak’s works exemplify complex interplays of literary, cultural, and market forces that influence canonization prospects in real time. The research conducted by questionnaires among contemporary readers and supplemented by the data provided by the Zagreb City Libraries on the most borrowed literary titles from 2013 to 2018, critical reception and available data on most sold books in the bookstores, draws on Bruno Latour’s actor-network theory (ANT), as interpreted by Rita Felski, which views literary texts as nonhuman actors that move through space and time and establish numerous relationships, thereby ensuring their visibility and longevity. The results of the research reveal consciously assumed obligations and responsibilities associated with the role of professional readers, as well as the power of impression as the strongest motive and criterion for evaluation among non professional readers. Both categories of readers confirm the value of Novak’s novels, and the analysis of borrowed titles from the Zagreb City Libraries over a five-year period complements the picture of their popularity and provides insight into the evaluation process as the result of the mutual interaction of a network of co-actors. The study analyses award recognition, critical reception, and readership patterns, illustrating how Novak’s novels have garnered broad acceptance and critical acclaim. Analysis of connections and actions of co actors confirms the hypothesis that literary texts are active participants in the process of evaluation. Through network theory perspectives, literary texts are treated as nodes within webs of relations, where succ

Fields of Study & Subjects

Literary Theory and Cultural Hermeneutics Contemporary Literature and Criticism Libraries Manuscripts and Books

Publication details

Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Thesis