Adolescents’ Literacy Learning in Out-of-School Spaces: A Scoping Review Protocol

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: James Chisholm, Amy Seely Flint, Courtney Shareef, Latisha Reynolds, Pardis Amiridahaj, Amy Eisenback, Mariem Riahi, Tyra G. Deckard, Jillian Pearsall
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Overview: Adolescent literacy has been paired with the word “crisis” throughout much of the recent literature (Franzak, 2006). Previous empirical research (Moje et al., 2008) and reviews of literature on adolescent literacy (Vasudevan & Campano, 2009) take issue with the notion that an adolescent literacy “crisis” actually exists, and do so by examining the varied ways in which adolescents engage in myriad generative literacy practices in out-of-school settings. Although literature reviews on adolescents’ out-of-school literacies have been conducted, they are relatively dated and narrow in scope, focusing on theoretical underpinnings (Hull & Schultz, 2001), examining out-of-school writing practices (Vaughn, 2020), or highlighting the characteristics of out-of-school programs (Kirkland & Hull, 2011; Moje & Tysvaer, 2010). Significant policy, technological, and sociocultural shifts have transformed how adolescent literacy is practiced in and out of schools over the last 25 years. For marginalized youth, who can become disengaged from traditional literacy practices taught in schools, community-based organizations and other out-of-school learning contexts can provide a significant foundation for literacy development. To trace these transformations for marginalized adolescents’ literacy learning in out-of-school spaces, we engage in a scoping review of the literature. Rationale: Knowing the breadth of evidence available can help to focus future empirical studies in this area on the most salient issues affecting adolescents’ out-of-school literacy learning. Mapping the existing evidence can also inform educational policy to support adolescent development. By charting the characteristics of out-of-school adolescent literacy programs, we can learn about elements that are widely practiced and others that are not. Objective: The objective of this scoping review is to identify from 2000-2025 the evidence available on community-based literacy outcomes for marginalized adolescents. Methods and Analysis Our scoping review and protocol will follow Arksey & O’Malley’s (2005) five-stage methodological framework. We will use the Scoping Review extension of the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analysis Protocols (PRISMA-ScR) for writing the protocol and for the final scoping review manuscript. The stages involve Identifying the Research Question (Stage 1), Identifying Relevant Studies (Stage 2), Study Selection (Stage 3), Charting the Data (Stage 4), and Collating, Summarizing and Reporting Results (Stage 5). An education librarian developed the search strategy for this scoping review in consultation with an interdisciplinary social sciences librarian. The finalized strategy will include searching titles, abstracts, and major subject headings of relevant bibliographic databases. It will also include a manual search of reference list and key journals and/or association websites for additional relevant studies. We identified the EBSCO interface for the Education Resource Information Center (ERIC) as our primary/core database because of its robust thesaurus. We developed the search strategy below, which was refined after undergoing the Peer Review of Electronic Search Strategies (PRESS) checklist process by a librarian at an external institution. The primary search strategy will be translated to other education and multi-disciplinary databases, including Academic Search Complete (EBSCO), APA PsycInfo (EBSCO), Dissertations & Theses Global (ProQuest), Education Full Text (ProQuest), and Education Research Index (ProQuest). We will also search and screen from Google Scholar the first 100 unique results. Additionally, we will manually backward- and forward-trace reference lists of included studies and may search for additional grey literature through the targeted website browsing of relevant associations, research centers, and more. We structured our research question using the PCC Framework: Population – Concept – Context. Our research team established the criteria for inclusion and exclusion listed in the table below. Articles will be de-duplicated and screened in Covidence. To ensure all team members understand the eligibility criteria and apply their distinctions consistently, we will conduct pilots at each stage of the screening (title and abstract, full-text). This will allow the team to review decisions (Yes, No, Maybe) and discuss the rationale for making those determinations. Titles and abstracts will be independently screened by two reviewers. A third reviewer will resolve any disagreements. Researchers are instructed to automatically advance ambiguous articles (i.e., those without abstracts) to the full-text screening. The results of the search and screening will be reported using the PRISMA-ScR flow diagram. We intend to use Microsoft Excel to annotate each article for the following information: citation, year study took place, research question, research design, methodology, data sources, number of participants, participant demographics, participant identities, context of study (i.e., site), region where study took place, rationale for intervention, theoretical framework, definition of literacy, literacy artifacts, outcomes, and study limitations. Ethics and Dissemination Ethics approval is not necessary. Dissemination will occur through academic conferences such as the Literacy Research Association and academic journals such as the Review of Educational Research. We will also disseminate the results of this review to local stakeholders who support adolescents’ literacy learning in out-of-school spaces.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Literacy Media and Education Youth Development and Social Support Literacy and Educational Practices

Publication details

Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Preprint