Direct or Indirect Realism? Assessing Conflicting Folk Conceptions of Vision

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Eugen Fischer, Keith Allen, Paul Edward Engelhardt, Nina Haket
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

This project contains data from three studies developing and validating the Direct/Indirect Realist Belief Inventory (DIRBI), a psychometric instrument assessing lay beliefs about the nature of visual perception. Philosophical debates about perception have long assumed that 'the' common-sense view of vision is Direct Realist — that in seeing an object, we are simply aware of the object itself, not of any mental image. Indirect Realism holds the opposite: that vision involves awareness of a mental image caused by, and representing, the physical object. The present studies examine whether this philosophical assumption is empirically warranted, by testing whether laypeople hold Direct Realist beliefs, Indirect Realist beliefs, or both. Study 1 (N = 500, UK Prolific) administered an agreement rating task with 48 verbal items across 8 subscales (Perceptual Direct/Indirect, Perceptual Causal Direct/Indirect, Phenomenal Direct/Indirect, Epistemic Direct/Indirect), rated on a 7-point scale, followed by 7 short animations depicting different conceptions of vision. Exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses examined the factor structure of responses. Study 2 (N = 319, UK Prolific) used a refined 32-item version of the inventory (4 items per subscale) and 4 animations, replicating and extending the factor analyses from Study 1. A subset of 40 participants returned for a follow-up session 4–5 weeks later. Study 3 (N = 59, UK Prolific, two timepoints ~3–4 weeks apart) assessed the test-retest reliability of the refined DIRBI and examined whether the beliefs measured by the inventory are deployed in judgment and reasoning tasks. Findings provide evidence of a stable two-factor structure (a Direct Realist factor and an Indirect Realist factor), high test-retest reliability, and that a non-negligible proportion of participants simultaneously endorse both conceptions — suggesting that common sense is itself torn between mutually incompatible views of vision. Contents: Three datasets (Study 1: N = 500; Study 2: N = 319; Study 3: N = 59, test-retest) and a README with full variable descriptions and coding information. ORCID Identifiers Eugen Fischer 0000-0003-2088-1610 Keith Allen 0000-0002-3219-2102 Paul E. Engelhardt 0000-0001-9699-2101 Corresponding author: Eugen Fischer, e.fischer@uea.ac.uk

Fields of Study & Subjects

Philosophy and Theoretical Science Visual perception and processing mechanisms Epistemology Ethics and Metaphysics

Publication details

Journal / source
OSF Preprints (OSF Preprints)
Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Preprint