Abstract
This study is an extended analysis of the data originally collected by Molho et al. (2020) in their experience sampling investigation of social norm violation punishment decisions. The original study focused on direct and indirect punishment motivations and behaviours in response to social norm violations. The authors found that people express stronger motivations to punish social norm violators through indirect punishment (i.e. gossip and social exclusion) compared to direct punishment (i.e. physical and verbal confrontation) (Molho et al., 2020). They also found that people’s actual behaviours follow a similar pattern, where they more often engaged in indirect punishments in the form of gossip in response to social norm violations (Molho et al., 2020). One key variable that was not examined in this past project is the number of people that are present in a situation in which a norm violation took place. This is important from the decades-long research tradition on the bystander effect (Darley & Latané, 1968). Several novel questions can be addressed, especially because the dataset includes various theoretically distinct measures of direct and indirect punishment. For example, are people more likely to engage in confrontation when there are less bystanders? And if so, may people rely on indirect punishment such as gossip or exclusion when the number of bystanders increases? The dataset we utilize did not collect any data in inaction as a response to a social norm violation, instead analyzing indirect and direct punishment motivations/behaviours. Molho et al. (2020) discuss when people deploy different forms of punishment, discussing that people choose specific punishment strategies that are conditional to the costs and benefits of those punishment behaviours. Direct punishment (physical or verbal confrontation) can be risky because they open one up to potential retaliation, but it is also fast and effective at adjusting unwanted behaviour and leaves little to interpretation. Indirect punishments (gossip or social avoidance) have less risks of retaliation but can also be less effective at stopping unwanted behaviours quickly. The authors discuss five rules relevant to punishment decisions. The first two focus on the benefits of punishment, where circumstances when the offender is a highly valued individual and the violation is self-focused lead to greater rewards. The next two rules focus on minimizing the risk of retaliation, where circumstances of severe violations with powerful offenders should motivate safer choices. And the last rule implicates the role of negative emotions as a primary motivator for punishment choices. The bystander effect states that when there are passive bystanders present in a critical situation, an individual’s likelihood to help, intervene, or involve oneself in the situation decreases (Chekroun, 2008; Fischer et al., 2011). Bystander literature has found that when there is a larger number of bystanders present, the magnitude of the bystander effect also increases (Fischer et al., 2011). Some possible explanations for this phenomenon have been attributed to diffusion of responsibility (division of responsibility to help across all those present), evaluation apprehension (fear of judgement after public action), and pluralistic ignorance (reliance on other’s reactions when defining ambiguous situations) (Latané & Darley, 1970). Other psychological processes hypothesized to be involved include social control, social influence and audience inhibition, and evolutionary/game theory concepts such as altruism and inclusive fitness (Chekroun, 2008; Fischer et al., 2011). Latane and Darley (1970) also proposed a five step model to explain when a bystander would take action; (1) notice the situation, (2) define it an emergency, (3) feel responsible to intervene, (4) reflect on how to help, (5) decide to intervene and take action. The presence of bystanders is thought to interfere with this process, particularly at the feeling of responsibility phase because of our tendency towards diffusion of responsibility. Even though one might think that a “strength in numbers” mindset might embolden individuals, the opposite is true, and with more people, the perceived shared responsibility to act is widely spread, inhibiting a motivation for action. This extends past physical, in-person scenarios, with research examining responses to cyberbullying finding that with larger numbers of bystanders, people felt less responsible to help and were less willing to intervene (Obermaier et al., 2016). The bystander effect has been primarily examined in the context of emergencies, such as situations in which another person faces acute health problems (e.g., epileptic attack), danger (e.g., smoke coming into a room), or aggression (e.g., a physical or verbal threat). The present research focuses on norm violations, which are psychologically very different. Notably, in classic bystander situations, intervention often means solving the problem, as in the classic case of Kitty Genovese (Darley & Latané, 1968). Yet an intervention in norm violations is less strongly aimed at helping. Instead, it is often focused on informal norm enforcement, seeking to correct a person’s behavior or to discourage the person from engaging in such norm violations. As another difference, time matters less in situations in which one faces norm violations versus emergencies. And as a third difference, it is possible that in norm violations, confrontation may be a form of direct (and visible) punishment that is more likely to be enacted when other people are present, especially for stronger forms of norm violations. The present study seeks to examine variables relating to group size and bystander presence to investigate the effect of number of bystanders present on punishment motivations and behaviours (indirect and direct) in response to others’ social norm violations (H1). Additionally, we investigate how situational factors (i.e. norm violation severity) and relational variables (i.e. interpersonal closeness with victim and interpersonal closeness with offender) impact punishment behaviours, moderated by the number of bystanders present (H2/3). Besides the investigation of punishment decisions of norm violations, this study also touches on two underexplored topics. The first is studying the bystander effect in non-emergent situations such as during daily norm violations, and the second is studying the bystander effect in the presence of close others as opposed to the field standard of strangers. Keeping these in mind, this study has great potential to contribute novel and widely relevant findings to norm violation, punishment decision, and bystander effect research. Note. The original study did not test any hypotheses focused on the effect of bystander presence and context. The present study will not re-test the original hypotheses and looks to provide an extension of the original study, focusing on new theoretical questions and utilizing previously unused variables. We advancing competing hypotheses, framed as A and B, because there are multiple theoretical perspectives that guide the opposing hypotheses.