Abstract
This systematic scoping review synthesises the existing review literature on keratoconus to establish an evidence-based foundation for international consensus. Following PRISMA-ScR reporting guidelines, we conducted a comprehensive search identifying 309 review articles (narrative reviews, systematic reviews, meta-analyses, scoping reviews, and other review types) published between 2015 and 2026. Quality assessment was performed using SANRA (Scale for the Assessment of Narrative Review Articles) for 209 narrative and non-systematic reviews, and AMSTAR-2 (A MeaSurement Tool to Assess systematic Reviews) for 100 systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Of the 309 reviews, 215 (69.6%) were rated High quality, 24 (7.8%) Moderate, 33 (10.7%) Low, and 37 (12.0%) Critically Low. Evidence was extracted and synthesised across 15 pre-defined clinical and scientific domains: Definition, Epidemiology, Histopathology, Aetiology and Risk Factors, Clinical Presentation and Quality of Life, Detection and Diagnosis, Classification and Staging, Corneal Collagen Cross-Linking, Non-Surgical Management, Surgical Management, Biomechanics, Artificial Intelligence and Technology, Paediatric Keratoconus, Genetics, and Regenerative Approaches. Domain-level synthesis followed the Popay narrative synthesis framework, incorporating sub-topic classification, quality-weighted evidence mapping, and cross-domain co-occurrence analysis. Each domain produced an audit workbook documenting the classification of all 309 papers against domain-specific sub-topics with supporting evidence, and a narrative synthesis document containing consensus statements graded using a modified GRADE (Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation) framework adapted for scoping reviews of reviews. Cross-domain analysis identified eight overarching themes and generated 20 overarching consensus statements synthesised from 48 domain-level statements. A tiered research priority agenda of 16 priorities was developed to guide future investigation. The review identified the absence of a standardised definition for subclinical keratoconus as the most critical unresolved gap, with cascading implications for detection protocols, classification systems, epidemiological estimates, and treatment indications.