Expecting Together: Optimizing Expectations during Shared Decision-Making for Enhanced Childbirth Pain Management.

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Elisabeth Helene Achteresch, Kaya J. Peerdeman
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Patients’ expectations about their health can shape their actual health. Most notably, research into placebo and nocebo effects has taught us that positive expectations about treatment outcome can be beneficial (e.g., causing pain relief), while negative expectations can be harmful (e.g., causing pain worsening) (1). Theoretical (Bayesian) models moreover pose that stronger expectations yield larger effects (2). However, recent research shows that unrealistically positive expectations can backfire, causing, for example, increased fear and disappointment upon their violation (3,4). Taken together, expectancy research indicates that healthcare providers can improve health by communicating positive, yet realistic expectations about treatment outcomes and health. Applying insights from expectancy research to the widely advocated practice of shared decision-making on treatment is a largely unrecognized, but highly promising avenue for eliciting significant health benefits (5,6). In shared decision-making, healthcare providers inform patients on treatment options to form balanced expectations and collaboratively choose a treatment, considering the individual patient’s preferences and circumstances (7). While shared decision-making may improve patients’ decisions (e.g., reduced decisional conflict) and satisfaction, its impact on health outcomes, such as pain, is less clear (8). We pose that health outcomes will likely be improved when optimizing expectations during shared decision-making. A specific situation where merging these approaches could have profound impact is childbirth pain management. Childbirth is one of life’s most intense physical experiences and prevalent, with around 165.000 births annually in the Netherlands (9). A key challenge in maternity care is the high prevalence of negative childbirth experiences, with potential long-term consequences for mother and child (e.g., posttraumatic stress disorder) (10,11). Women’s anticipation of childbirth pain can contribute to this, including excessive fear of childbirth (with fear of pain as a core element) (12) and, conversely, unrealistically positive and inflexible childbirth (pain) expectations (13). Some research indicates benefits of shared decision-making using a birth plan (a document in which women indicate their preferences for childbirth, like pain management)(14), but it has been criticized for promoting unrealistic and inflexible expectations and, consequently, negative experiences upon their likely violation(4). Thus, expectation management requires specific attention during shared decision-making regarding childbirth pain management. The project’s aim is to determine if optimizing expectations (expectation optimization, EO) during shared-decision making on childbirth pain management (birth plan consultation) can improve women’s pain and childbirth expectations and experiences, as compared to treatment as usual (TAU).

Fields of Study & Subjects

Pain Management and Placebo Effect Patient-Provider Communication in Healthcare Maternal and Perinatal Health Interventions

Publication details

Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Preprint