The Acquisition of Agency Metacognition During Motor Exploration in a Hand Gesture–Controlled Visuomotor Projection Paradigm

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Yosuke Suzuishi, Wen Wen
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Sense of agency (SoA) refers to the feeling of controlling one’s body and the external environment. Traditionally, SoA is explained by the comparator model, which posits that SoA arises from a match between predicted and actual action outcomes (Blakemore et al., 1998). However, when we experience a new motor skill (e.g., when using a new device), we do not initially have predictions about the outcomes of our actions. Instead, we gradually develop an internal model of the action–outcome mapping through trial and error, a process known as motor exploration. Tanaka and Imamizu (2025) employed a de novo motor learning task that participants had never experienced before. In their study, participants controlled a cursor using a mapping from hand posture to cursor position derived from principal component analysis (PCA). Before learning the mapping, SoA for the cursor was driven primarily by the temporal contiguity between finger movements and cursor movements. However, after participants learned the spatial hand-to-screen mapping through motor exploration, SoA increased for cursor movements that followed the learned mapping. These results suggest that SoA for a new motor skill emerges through the formation of a new internal model via motor exploration. However, it remains unclear how the metacognition of SoA develops. Moreover, Tanaka and Imamizu (2025) presented only a single cursor and examined whether participants felt SoA over it. This reflects a self-attribution process. In contrast, Wen et al. (2016) proposed an agency paradigm with multiple objects, requiring participants to identify a target object over which they had a certain level of control, while having no control over the other objects (also see Wen & Imamizu, 2022). Such a paradigm investigates self–other discrimination underlying SoA. It remains unclear how self–other discrimination and self-attribution, as well as the metacognitive monitoring of these processes, develop during the acquisition of SoA. In the self-control judgment task, participants evaluate whether a single cursor is controlled by themselves or by another source. In contrast, in the self-control detection task, participants identify the self-controlled cursor by comparing multiple cursors presented simultaneously. Consequently, this task relies on comparisons among the cursors, which may lead to differences in how participants monitor their agency judgments. Therefore, this study examines how the metacognition of SoA develops and whether metacognitive monitoring of agency differs between the self-control judgment task (i.e., self-attribution) and the self-control detection task (i.e., self-other discrimination). In this study, we use an infrared hand-tracking device (Stereo IR 170 Camera Module Kit, Ultraleap) to track participants’ hand gestures. We constructed two separate PCA models from four gestures, with each PCA model derived from two gestures. The first principal component of one PCA model was assigned to the X-axis, whereas the first principal component of the other PCA model was assigned to the Y-axis. Participants’ hand posture data are projected onto these PCA models, and the resulting principal component values are used as the X and Y components of the cursor movement vector. In the experiment, participants perform three tasks in each trial. First, participants perform a target-reaching task. In this task, a target appears at one of four locations (top, bottom, left, or right), and participants are required to reach the target using the cursor as many times as possible within 10 s. Only one target appears at a time; when the target is reached, it disappears, and a new target appears at a different location. This task serves as an exploration task. Second, a self-control judgment task is conducted. Participants freely control a cursor for 5 s and judge whether the cursor movement is controlled by themselves or generated from a pre-recorded motion. In this task, the speed of the cursor is determined by the participants’ gestures, whereas the direction of the cursor is determined by the pre-recorded motion when the cursor movement is generated from a pre-recorded motion. Participants also rate their confidence in their response using a four-point scale (1 = “My response is very likely incorrect”; 4 = “My response is very likely correct”). This task is repeated twice in each trial, with the cursor controlled by the participant once and by the pre-recorded motion once. The order of these conditions is randomized for each participant, while the number of trials for each condition is balanced. Third, participants perform a self-control detection task. In this task, three identical cursors are presented on the display. One cursor is controlled by the participant, whereas the other two move according to pre-recorded motions, as in the self-control judgment task. Participants control the cursors for 5 s and are required to detect the self-controlled cursor. They then select the cursor they believe they control and rate their confidence in the choice using the same four-point scale as in the self-control judgment task. Participants repeat these tasks for 90 trials. No practice session is provided because participants can learn the motor skill during the experimental trials.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Free Will and Agency Motor Control and Adaptation Action Observation and Synchronization

Publication details

Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Preprint