POLITICIZED CONSUMPTION IN POLARIZED ENVIRONMENTS: AN EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTS OF AFFECTIVE POLARIZATION ON BOYCOTT, BUYCOTT, AND CANCELLATION MEDIATED BY BRAND ACTIVISM AND MODERATED BY SOCIAL NORMS AND POLITICAL POSITIONING.

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: JAILSON LANA, Pablo Flôres Limberger
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

This research investigates how affective polarization is converted into instrumental responses of consumer activism in the face of sociopolitical positions adopted by brands. It is grounded in the understanding that, in contexts of intense political and identity fragmentation, corporate manifestations on controversial issues cease to be interpreted solely in terms of their substantive content and begin to operate as signals of symbolic alignment with specific political groups. In this environment, consumption and non-purchase come to assume an expressive, moralized, and sanctioning character, materializing in responses such as buycott, boycott, and cancellation. The central problem of the research arises from the fact that the literature has already demonstrated the relevance of the political environment to consumer behavior and market activism, but still lacks greater theoretical integration regarding the mechanism through which intergroup dispositions are translated into individual decisions to purchase or not purchase. In particular, there is a gap in understanding how affective polarization, understood as the combination of favoritism toward one’s own group and animosity toward the opposing group, influences the interpretation of corporate conduct and is transformed into concrete instrumental responses directed at brands. The dissertation argues that, in politically polarized markets, consumers do not always react only to the substantive cause involved, but rather to the political and identity-based meaning that this cause acquires when it is incorporated by a brand, thereby functioning as a marker of in-group and out-group. The project proposes an integrative theoretical model in which affective polarization acts as a motivational antecedent, perceived brand activism functions as a mediating mechanism, and the social norms of the relevant group and the brand’s post-stance response operate as moderating conditions of the intensity and direction of instrumental responses. The central premise is that affective polarization increases the consumer’s readiness to interpret the market through intergroup lenses, but this predisposition does not automatically turn into action. For this to occur, the consumer must perceive the brand’s conduct as politically meaningful, that is, as an interpretable signal of alignment, opposition, omission, or inconsistency. Perceived brand activism therefore constitutes the explanatory link that translates identity-based readiness into marketplace behavior. The general objective of the research is to propose and test an explanatory mechanism of how affective polarization is converted into instrumental responses of consumer activism, understood as boycott, buycott, and cancellation, in individual decisions of purchase and non-purchase, through perceived brand activism and under the influence of the social norms of the relevant group and the brand’s post-stance response. More specifically, the study seeks to develop an integrative theoretical model among these constructs, produce evidence of validity and reliability for the instruments used, examine the association between affective polarization and instrumental responses, test the mediating role of perceived brand activism, assess the moderating effect of group social norms, and analyze how different subsequent brand responses alter the strength and direction of consumer reactions. The theoretical foundation of the research is primarily anchored in Social Identity Theory and Self-Categorization Theory. From this basis, it is understood that belonging to political and ideological groups organizes individuals’ social perception and influences their judgments about market actors. In contexts of affective polarization, brands cease to be seen merely as economic agents and come to be categorized as symbolic allies or rivals. Within this logic, buycott, boycott, and cancellation are understood as instrumental responses congruent with intergroup dynamics, through which consumers reward brands perceived as close to their own group and punish brands perceived as associated with the opposing group, or react negatively to omission when they expect explicit support on issues considered morally salient to their own political camp. Methodologically, the research will be developed through a sequence of articulated experimental studies. The first study will seek to establish the total effect of exposure to politicized corporate signals on intentions to buycott, boycott, and cancel. At this stage, the focus lies on the association between affective polarization and instrumental responses congruent with intergroup logic, observing whether more polarized consumers demonstrate a greater tendency to reward brands perceived as aligned with the in-group and to punish brands perceived as aligned with the out-group. The second study will examine the mediating mechanism of the dissertation. Its objective will be to test whether perceived brand activism explains the association between affective polarization and instrumental consumer responses. In this context, the study will compare situations in which the brand explicitly adopts a sociopolitical position with situations in which it adopts a non-positioning stance. The theoretical expectation is that perceived activism functions as the interpretive filter that transforms affective predisposition into a concrete response. When the brand’s position is perceived as congruent with the consumer’s group, an increase in buycott intention is expected. When it is perceived as incongruent, an increase in boycott and cancellation intentions is expected. Additionally, in cases in which the brand chooses not to position itself on an issue considered important to the consumer’s group, omission is expected to be interpreted as a moral failure or expectation violation, increasing boycott intention among co-partisan consumers. The third study will analyze the moderating role of the social norms of the relevant group. It is assumed that individual decisions of politicized consumption do not occur in psychological isolation, but are influenced by perceptions of what the group does and what the group approves of. For this reason, the study will incorporate descriptive norms and injunctive norms as moderators of the relationship between perceived brand activism and instrumental responses. The expectation is that, under greater normative salience, the effect of perceived activism on boycott, cancellation, and buycott will be intensified, since norms function as mechanisms of validation and social pressure, reducing uncertainty in individual decision-making and reinforcing the identity coherence of behavior. The fourth study will introduce the temporal and strategic dimension of post-stance. This study will seek to understand how the brand’s subsequent response, following the initial controversy, reconfigures consumer interpretations and alters instrumental responses. Responses such as maintaining the stance with clarification, withdrawal with an apology, and silent withdrawal will be considered. The theoretical logic is that subsequent management of the stance acts as a signal of authenticity, consistency, or opportunism. It is expected that maintaining the stance with clarification will preserve or strengthen buycott among co-partisan consumers and sustain boycott and cancellation among counter-partisan consumers. In contrast, forms of retreat, especially when perceived as inconsistent or opportunistic, are expected to reduce buycott and increase punitive reactions, including through cross-punishment among publics that originally occupied different positions. The expected results are situated at different levels. At the theoretical level, the research is expected to contribute to the advancement of the literature by shifting the explanation of instrumental consumption responses away from an axis centered exclusively on the cause itself toward a model that emphasizes its political and identity-based reading in contexts of affective polarization. It is also expected to offer a more robust causal explanation for the transition from intergroup predisposition to the interpretation of corporate conduct and marketplace action, integrating contributions from political psychology, the brand activism literature, and the field of consumer activism. At the empirical level, evidence is expected to show that affective polarization is positively associated with instrumental responses congruent with intergroup logic. It is also expected that perceived brand activism will mediate this effect, functioning as the central explanatory mechanism through which polarization is converted into behavior. In addition, the social norms of the relevant group are expected to amplify the strength of instrumental reactions by providing legitimacy and behavioral direction for individual action. Finally, the brand’s post-stance response is expected to significantly alter the intensity and direction of buycott, boycott, and cancellation, demonstrating that the impact of brand activism does not end with the initial message, but is reconfigured by the organization’s subsequent conduct. At the methodological and conceptual level, the research also intends to contribute by treating boycott, buycott, and cancellation as individual, private, and often uncoordinated micro-decisions that are nevertheless capable of generating relevant aggregate effects on demand, reputation, and the social legitimacy of brands. This approach shifts the focus from explicitly organized collective movements to everyday and silent forms of consumer activism, making it possible to capture dimensions of the phenomenon that escape analyses centered only on public campaigns or visible collective mobilizations. At the practical level, the research is expected to offer guidance for the strategic management of brands in polarized environments by demonstrating that the risk and opportuni

Fields of Study & Subjects

Consumer Behavior in Brand Consumption and Identification Consumer behavior in food and health Environmental Sustainability in Business

Publication details

Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Preprint