Phase 10: Congressional Trade Disclosure Drift (PPTAD): A Pre-Registered Leadership-Weighted Monthly Signal Test and Incremental PEAD Value Analysis, CRSP Large-Cap 2013-2024

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Sungmin Hong
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

The STOCK Act (2012) requires US members of Congress to disclose equity trades within 30-45 calendar days of execution. Lazzaretto (2024, SSRN 4816497) documents +90 basis points of cumulative abnormal return in the 30 days following a senator's disclosure filing — identifying the public filing date, not the execution date, as the information event. This post-disclosure drift is what I term Post-Politician-Trades Announcement Drift (PPTAD). Its existence is, however, contested: Belmont, Sacerdote & Van Hoek (2022, Journal of Public Economics 207) find aggregate senator portfolios underperform benchmarks by 11–28 bps over 1–3 months in the same post-STOCK Act period. Wei & Zhou (2025, NBER w34524) reconcile these findings through leadership heterogeneity: rank-and-file members show no excess return, while congressional leaders (committee chairs, floor leaders) exhibit substantially higher performance following their trade disclosures. This study tests PPTAD as a monthly cross-sectional return predictor on the CRSP large-cap universe (NYSE 50th percentile floor, SIC excl. financials/utilities, 2013-01 to 2024-12, N ≈ 400–550 stocks/month). The primary data source is the official US Senate Electronic Financial Disclosure system (efts.senate.gov) and House Clerk Periodic Transaction Report database (disclosures.house.gov); CapitolTrades is used solely for reconciliation and amendment detection. Three pre-registered hypotheses are tested under Holm step-down FWER ≤ 0.10 (k=3). The primary statistic for Holm inference is the block-bootstrap mean monthly cumulative abnormal return (CAR, disclosure_date to disclosure_date+30, circular block bootstrap block=6, N=5000, seed=42). Monthly Spearman IC is reported as a secondary statistic for cross-programme consistency with Phases 3–6 of this programme. H2 (rank-1, threshold α/3=0.033): Mean monthly CAR for leadership-weighted disclosures is significantly positive over 2013–2024. Leadership tiers follow Wei & Zhou (2025): Committee Chairs/Ranking Members and floor leaders (weight 3), subcommittee chairs/ranking members (weight 2), rank-and-file (weight 1). H2 is the primary confirmatory test. H3 (rank-2, threshold α/2=0.050): Mean monthly CAR of a composite signal (equal-weight combination of leadership-weighted PPTAD and Phase 3 TS-SUE) exceeds the mean CAR of the SUE-only baseline. Equal weighting is pre-committed as the minimum-degrees-of-freedom combination rule and was not informed by observed IC values. H3 is confirmatory only if H2 (rank-1) passes. Note: the Phase 3 large-cap SUE baseline has IC=+0.0065 (BB p=0.1484, not significant); H3 therefore tests "PPTAD incremental to a weak baseline," not "incremental to an established PEAD signal." H1 (rank-3, threshold α/1=0.100): Mean monthly CAR for unconditional (unweighted) PPTAD disclosures is significantly positive. Expected to be null based on Belmont et al. (2022); serves as a context-setting replication of the aggregate signal. Known limitations stated ex ante: (i) Wei & Zhou (2025) is an NBER working paper not yet peer-reviewed; (ii) the IC framework is structurally underpowered for the 0.005 materiality gate (MDE ≈ 0.021); CAR is primary precisely for this reason; (iii) ~15–20% of STOCK Act filings lack a usable ticker and will not match to CRSP PERMNOs; PERMNO match fraction is reported in the coverage audit; (iv) politician trades are heavily concentrated in tech and pharma — sector-neutralised CAR is a required robustness check (§9.2); (v) the large-cap universe used here is the universe where PEAD was previously null in this programme (Phase 3 BB p=0.1484). This phase is one component of the AlphaSniper research programme, which has tested 4 independent signal families across 9 prior phases.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Financial Markets and Investment Strategies Corporate Finance and Governance Political Influence and Corporate Strategies

Publication details

Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Preprint