Abstract
The following study has been motivated by the initial results from 149 participants in a previous pre-registered study (10.17605/OSF.IO/P5BXM). The theoretical framework and literature remain largely unchanged; however, the operational definition of the discovery of innovation has been refined to more precisely capture serendipitous innovation. Innovation is a key element of cumulative cultural evolution, or the accumulation of increasingly efficient or effective strategies of solutions (Fogarty et al., 2015; Mesoudi & Thornton, 2018). In many innovation-related settings, individuals learn the structure of a task, explore new strategies, and then decide whether to persist with familiar strategies or adapt to changing circumstances. Because innovation is a key driver of progress in society (Krlev, 2020), researchers are increasingly focused on understanding the factors that promote it. Hoppitt & Laland (2013) proposed the mechanisms for innovation, including modification or combination of existing behaviours, trial and error and “happy accidents”. The latter refers broadly to unexpected events or outcomes that can be recognised and used in ways that lead to novel solutions. The following study will focus on this process to investigate factors that affect our ability to recognise, evaluate, and exploit these “happy accidents”. When discussing possible factors that create it, innovation can be the result of expertise. In the case of complex technologies, it has been argued that experts are best placed to fully understand and exploit innovations in their area (Lee et al., 2019; Rycroft & Cash, 1999). Other studies point to the relationship between creativity and executive functions (Paz-Baruch & Maor, 2023), particularly between creative cognition and memory (Gerver et al., 2023; Gong, 2023). Other studies have also shown that the relationship between the ability to discover and use the affordances of innovations are related to cognitive flexibility to switch between strategies and contexts (Carr et al., 2017, Pan & Yu, 2016). With this in mind, we plan to investigate whether expertise and executive functions might improve people’s ability to recognise, understand, and exploit the affordances of an innovation discovered serendipitously, by “happy accident”. The study will place participants in an environment where they can, by chance, discover a new behavioural strategy when playing a game. This “innovation” doubles the points they obtain when clicking on a cell. This can be good if applied to a cell with a positive score, e.g. 2 becomes 4; or bad, if applied to a cell with a negative score, e.g., –2 becomes –4. For the purposes of this study, innovation will be operationalised as the discovery of this serendipitous variant (i.e., the ‘double-click’). In contrast to the previous preregistration, the occurrence of double-clicking and the noticing of double-clicking will be operationalised as two separate indicators. The occurrence of double-clicking is defined as a participant performing at least one double-click (two clicks within 500 ms) within the grid game, as determined from in-game click logs. Noticing of double-clicking is defined as participants explicitly reporting that they double-clicked during the game by answering “Yes” to the question “Did you use the double-click mechanism during the game?” on SurveyLab after playing the game. We will manipulate the degree of expertise participants can achieve within the game environment by changing the topographic layout of the points and we will measure their executive functions using the Short Executive Function Scale (SEFS; Karr, 2024). Participants’ total game score will be recorded in the game, thus giving a measure of their success, and they will be asked to indicate whether they discovered the serendipitous variant (i.e., finding the new variant), and to what extent they exploit it successfully to increase their score in the game (i.e., showcasing they understand the utilisation of the new variant). Therefore, we will test whether Expertise and Executive Functions influence the extent to which participants (a) notice the double-click, (b) understand what it does, and, (c) subsequently use it strategically in a task to maximise their score. We will use a game-based experiment and surveys to test this and will report the results in a PhD thesis chapter, in academic papers, and at conferences.