Replication Project - Falben et al. (2020)

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Mia Sutcliffe-Hill
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

This project is a direct simulated replication of Falbén et al. (2020), who investigated how prior beliefs and stimulus prevalence modulate self–other prioritisation in an object-ownership classification task. Across three experiments, Falbén et al. reported that self-prioritisation is not an obligatory perceptual advantage but a flexible, expectation-driven phenomenon: it emerges under stimulus uncertainty, is eliminated or reversed by prevalence manipulations, and is overridden by actual stimulus frequency even when this conflicts with prior expectations. We replicate all three experiments using the original 2×2 mixed factorial (Experiment 1), 3×2 repeated-measures (Experiment 2), and 2×2 repeated-measures (Experiment 3) designs. The task structure, stimuli (greyscale images of pens and pencils), timing parameters, expectancy manipulations, and exclusion criteria were reproduced as closely as possible, with the task programmed in Gorilla Experiment Builder. Trial-level response time and accuracy data were generated computationally using simulated participants, with response times modelled as condition-specific means plus participant-level random intercepts drawn from normal distributions, preserving realistic between-participant variability while targeting the marginal means reported in the original study. We predict that (1) self-prioritisation will emerge under stimulus uncertainty but be eliminated under equal probability; (2) prioritisation will track the expected ownership category rather than self-relevance per se, with friend-prioritisation emerging when friend-owned items predominate; and (3) actual stimulus prevalence will override conflicting prior expectations. We further predict that, at the mechanistic level, hierarchical drift diffusion modelling will attribute expectancy-linked effects primarily to shifts in starting point (response bias) rather than drift rate.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Visual perception and processing mechanisms Face Recognition and Perception Child and Animal Learning Development

Publication details

Journal / source
Open Science Framework
Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
EN