Abstract
This research project investigates how Spanish-speaking Latin American researchers perceive the indicators used in academic evaluation systems, with a particular focus on whether these indicators promote or discourage responsible research practices. In recent years, concerns have grown about the extent to which traditional metrics, such as publication counts, journal impact factors, and citation rates, shape research behavior, potentially incentivizing productivity and prestige over scientific integrity, openness, and societal relevance. This study aims to contribute to this debate by examining how researchers themselves evaluate the importance and impact of different types of indicators. Using a self-administered online survey, participants are asked to assess a range of academic evaluation indicators across four key dimensions: advancing science, career advancement, personal satisfaction, and social impact. The indicators include both responsible research practices (e.g., open access publishing, data sharing, replication, and publication of null results) and traditional prestige- or productivity-based measures (e.g., publishing in high-impact journals, citation counts, and publication volume). The study adopts a within-subjects design, allowing each participant to evaluate all indicators across all dimensions, thereby enabling direct comparison of perceived value. The primary objective of the project is to identify systematic differences in how these indicators are perceived across dimensions, and to test whether responsible research practices are valued less in terms of career advancement compared to their perceived contribution to science and society. Additionally, the study explores whether traditional metrics continue to dominate perceptions of career success. Complementing the quantitative analysis, qualitative responses are analyzed to better understand researchers’ views on whether current evaluation systems effectively support responsible research practices. The expected outcomes of this research include a clearer understanding of the alignment or misalignment between what researchers perceive as beneficial for science and society and what is rewarded in academic careers. The findings aim to inform ongoing discussions about research assessment reform, particularly in the Latin American context, and may provide evidence to support the development of more balanced and responsible evaluation frameworks that better incentivize high-quality, transparent, and socially relevant research.