Conflict Experience Modulates Flexibility-Stability Interplay: Cognitive Computational Mechanisms of the List-Wide Proportion Congruency Effect

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Linghe Li, Ling Wang
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

1. Background and Research Question Cognitive control enables adaptive behavior by maintaining task goals and resisting interference (cognitive stability) while flexibly switching between tasks in response to environmental changes (cognitive flexibility). A long-standing theoretical debate concerns whether these two functions operate in opposition (a trade-off) or are supported by relatively independent mechanisms that can be concurrently optimized. Recent evidence from the List-Wide Proportion Congruency (LWPC) paradigm offers new insights into this debate. When individuals are placed in a high-conflict environment (i.e., frequent interference), they show reduced congruency effects, indicating enhanced cognitive stability. However, it remains unclear whether this conflict-based learning influences cognitive flexibility, and what cognitive computational mechanisms underlie such adaptation. This study employs computational modeling to systematically investigate how the probability of response conflict modulates the dynamic interplay between cognitive flexibility and stability, aiming to reveal the computational mechanisms of adaptive learning based on conflict experience. 2. Research Objectives This study has two main objectives: First, behavioral characterization. We will examine how conflict proportion (30% congruent, 50% congruent, 70% congruent) modulates switch cost (reflecting flexibility) and congruency effect (reflecting stability), as well as their interaction. We expect reduced congruency effects under high-conflict conditions, while the pattern of switch cost changes will be explored empirically. Second, computational mechanism identification. Using the Diffusion Model of Conflict (DMC), we will decompose behavioral data into interpretable cognitive parameters (decision threshold, drift rate, conflict strength, etc.). By constructing and comparing multiple candidate models, we will identify which cognitive parameters are modulated by conflict proportion, thereby revealing the computational mechanisms of adaptive learning. 3. Methods Participants: Twenty healthy right-handed adults (aged 18-30 years) with normal or corrected-to-normal vision and no history of neurological or psychiatric disorders will be recruited. Sample size was determined using G*Power (α = 0.05, 1-β = 0.90, medium effect size). Design: A 2 (Task Sequence: repeat vs. switch) × 2 (Response Congruency: congruent vs. incongruent) × 3 (Conflict Proportion: 30% congruent, 50% congruent, 70% congruent) fully within-subjects design will be employed. The three conflict proportion conditions will be completed on separate days. The 50% congruent condition serves as the baseline and is fixed on the second day. The 30% and 70% congruent conditions are counterbalanced between the first and third days using a Latin square design (two possible orders, 10 participants each). Each condition includes 6 blocks of 320 trials, totaling 1,920 trials per condition. A practice block (160 trials) precedes each condition. Within each condition, repeat and switch trials each account for 50%, while the proportion of congruent and incongruent trials is determined by the conflict proportion condition. Task: A cued task-switching paradigm with simultaneous cue and stimulus presentation (CSI = 0 ms) will be used to maximize reactive control demands. Participants classify stimuli according to the task cue (solid frame = color task, dashed frame = shape task). Each trial consists of: fixation (500 ms) → cue and stimulus presented simultaneously (max 2000 ms) → blank screen (1000 ms). Computational Modeling: The Diffusion Model of Conflict (DMC) will be used. Model fitting will use the Simplex parameter estimation method (Nelder-Mead algorithm). Model comparison will use AIC and BIC. Statistical Analysis: Behavioral data will be analyzed using three-way repeated-measures ANOVA in SPSS. Cognitive parameters from the winning model will be subjected to 2 (Task Sequence) × 3 (Conflict Proportion) repeated-measures ANOVA. Post-hoc pairwise comparisons will use Bonferroni correction (α = 0.017). 4. Expected Outcomes Behavioral Level: We expect reduced congruency effects under high-conflict (mostly incongruent) conditions, indicating enhanced cognitive stability through learning. The pattern of switch cost changes will be determined empirically—if unchanged, flexibility is independent of conflict experience; if changed, conflict experience has a spillover effect on flexibility. Computational Level: Model comparison will identify the winning model, revealing the specific mechanism of adaptive learning. Theoretical Contribution: This study will reveal how the cognitive system adapts based on conflict experience at the mechanistic level, providing a computational framework for understanding the dynamic balance between flexibility and stability, and offering new perspectives for studying cognitive control dysfunction in clinical populations such as ADHD and OCD. 5. Significance This study addresses a fundamental question in cognitive science: How does the cognitive system learn adaptively based on conflict experience? Through computational modeling, we aim to provide a mechanistic account of adaptive learning, establishing quantitative links between cognitive processes and behavioral performance. The findings will contribute to advancing cognitive control theory from static description to dynamic mechanistic explanation, provide a computational framework for understanding cognitive control dysfunction in clinical populations, and inform the design of cognitive training interventions.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Neural and Behavioral Psychology Studies Neurobiology of Language and Bilingualism Cognitive Functions and Memory

Publication details

Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Preprint