Abstract
Social Identity Theory (SIT) posits that disadvantaged group members engage in collective action when they perceive the hierarchical stratification that defines their disadvantage to be unstable (Tajfel, 1981). While there is substantial evidence to support this proposition, recent findings challenge this perspective and identify conditions of stable disadvantage as unique predictors of nonnormative collective action instead (Scheepers et al., 2006; Tausch et al., 2011). This latter line of work, indeed, posits that conditions of inescapable or unchangeable (in other words stable) social disadvantage, affect radicalization among disadvantaged groups by increasing the appeal of forceful forms of action as strategic reactions to destabilize seemingly unmovable oppression. This is the idea at the core of the Nothing-to-Lose hypothesis of radicalization (NTL), which much more broadly, suggests that in situations of desperation (“when there is nothing left to lose…”) radicalization might come to be seen as an opportunity for social advancement (“… we do whatever it takes”) (Scheepers et al., 2006). While this proposition represents a valuable insight into the potential limitations of adopting a strict SIT understanding of mobilization among disadvantaged groups, the lack of clarity surrounding NTL’s claims (i.e., What do we mean when we speak of desperation? When does it ensue? What does it lead to?) and the consequent lack of experimental work and evidence to support its proposed rationale represents a great limitation for resolving the stability paradox in the collective action literature. The debate on stability considerations’ effect on nonnormative action are further complicated by the literature’s current understanding of the concept of efficacy. Since there is evidence to support that group efficacy acts both as a positive (Uysal et al., 2025; Zuniga et al., 2023) and negative (Tausch et al., 2011) predictor of nonnormative action, and efficacy and stability considerations have been treated as somewhat interchangeable concepts in past literature, this evidence further exacerbates the perceived incompatibility between the rationale underscoring the NTL idea, and the “activist profile” proposed in SIT’s framework. With the current experiment, our goal is to take a first step towards clarifying the causal relations between group member’s perceptions of stable disadvantage, and their attitudes towards radical collective action. To do this, we take a step back and through the acknowledgment of limitations in current conceptualizations of stability and efficacy, focus on an understudied, and what we consider intermediate-level factor between the two – what SIT defined as “cognitive alternatives”. Cognitive alternatives can be defined as feasible and accessible understandings of how the social structure that defines relevant status relations could be different, and importantly better, for one’s own group of belonging (Tajfel, 1978; Wright et al., 2022). We advance cognitive alternatives to sit at the intersection between structural- (or societal-) level considerations (i.e., stability) and more group-dependent psychological understandings of possibilities and capabilities for mobilization (i.e., efficacy), and as such to represent an essential construct to investigate more closely in the study of (group) radicalization. With this experiment we aim to artificially create conditions of stable and unstable disadvantage with low and high cognitive alternatives with the goal of testing if and the extent to which NTL and SIT can be considered compatible and complementary, rather than competing, understandings of collective mobilization. The experiment has a 2 (Stability: Stable disadvantage vs. Unstable disadvantage) x 2 (Cognitive Alternatives: Yes/High vs. No/Low) x 2 (Measures’ order: Pre- vs. Post-DVs measurement of mediators) x 3 (Collective action type: Normative vs. Non-violent nonnormative vs. Violent nonnormative) mixed design with within-subjects on the last factor. The proposed experimental procedure is a re-elaboration of Hannes Rosenbusch’s (2017, unpublished master's thesis) original paradigm. Participants (Ps) will be recruited via Prolific by placing an advertisement describing the study’s goal as that of supposedly testing the fictitious Two-Group-Theory in the UK’s context. Once redirected to the study, Ps will be asked to read more information about the study’s purposes, tasks, length and retribution. Importantly, because our goal is to understand when and why support for nonnormative action develops, an outcome particularly vulnerable to demand-effects, Ps will not be told about the experimental nature of the study, nor will they be fully informed about its goals, before being asked to provide their consent the first time. They will be fully debriefed at the end of the study and will also be asked consent a second time. The study received ethical approval from the University of St Andrews’ School of Psychology and Neuroscience’s Ethics Committee in February 2026. First, all Ps will be given more information about the theory the study aims to (supposedly) test. They will be informed of new findings suggesting that most of the world’s population can be divided into two macro social groups, namely community and ego agents. They will then be asked to complete a word-association task to determine their membership to either of the two macro social groups Albeit being presented as an established psychometric test, the word-association task has actually been designed to guarantee the allocation of Ps to the disadvantaged group of community-based agents (while excluding Ps who might not believe in the "arbitrary" group allocation). The arbitrary assignment of Ps to what will later be described in the study as the exploited group (vs. the exploit-ing group;, i.e., ego-agents), implies the development of a sense of threat to their (artificial) social identity which will allow the research team to study the dynamics which shape collective action. After the fake group allocation task, all participants will be asked to read what will appear as an abstract from an academic textbook describing "Two-Group Theory" in greater detail. At this stage Ps will be randomly allocated to either of two conditions manipulating the perceived stability of community-agents’ disadvantage. In the stable condition Ps will be given fake information to show community-agents’ conditions have not changed and are unlikely to change for the better in coming years vs. in the instability condition Ps will be told their group’s status has progressively improved and can continue to do so. Following the stability manipulation, Ps will be randomly allocated either to the high/yes vs. low/no cognitive alternatives’ conditions. To manipulate this construct, we will follow the procedure validated by Lutz et al. (2024) for which in the high/yes cognitive alternatives condition Ps will be asked to “think of ways in which the relation between community and ego agents (i.e., the exploiting group) could be different” vs. in the low/no cognitive alternatives condition Ps will be prompted to think of something unrelated to the relation between their group and that of ego-agents. At this stage Ps will be randomly allocated to either of the two “measures order” conditions. To verify whether measuring potential mediators in the relation between stability and nonnormative action impacts the effect of our manipulations, half of the Ps will be assessed on the mediators before being asked to complete the DVs, while the other half will first be asked to complete the DVs, and will then be presented with the mediators' measures. Overall, Ps will be asked to respond to manipulation checks, measures of intergroup emotions, collective self-esteem, hope, identification, legitimacy, group efficacy, support for different collective action strategies, demographics, and finally, questions about the believability of the cover story. The latter will be part of the funnel debriefing which will progressively probe into Ps opinions of the cover story and experimental paradigm. The study’s main objective is to test whether we can find support for the relation Stability --> Nonnormative Action (original NTL), and if this can be juxtaposed to the In-Stability --> Normative Action relation (SIT). We are further curious to understand if the current inconsistencies in findings about the relation between stability and efficacy, and different types of collective action, can more systematically be addressed by an explicit consideration of the impact of prompting (or not) cognitive alternatives to the current status quo. By testing cognitive alternatives’ moderating role in the stability --> nonnormative collective action relationship, we aim to test the strength of the original NTL understanding (i.e., stable condition with no cognitive alternatives) against a re-elaborated interpretation of the hypothesis, considerate of current findings supporting more proximal psychological considerations (i.e., efficacy) to be positive predictors of nonnormative action (i.e., stable condition with cognitive alternatives). A complete list of the study’s main hypotheses (with explanations) is provided in the pre-registration’s dedicated section.