Experimental evidence of messaging to encourage citizen activism in Indonesia

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Aurelia Salsabila Ananda, Elghafiky Bimardhika, Azzah Rana
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Our research project aims to test various narratives to increase political participation among ordinary Indonesians. The premise is motivated by findings from our previous survey, where we found that Indonesians hold a strong paternalistic (or family state) view of the government. These views established a specific perception of citizenship and political agency, namely that the government is conceptualised as a wise 'head of the family' that is to be obeyed and not challenged; that democracy is merely about free elections and orderly/courteous freedom of expression rather than about checks and balances on government power; and that non-electoral civic actions, such as lodging complaints or protesting, are seen as unnecessary, improper, or even rebellious. In response to this past survey, our research team followed up with a qualitative focus group discussion (FGD) to test several narratives in an attempt to shift perceptions around civic actions. Our FGD findings demonstrated success with two narratives: 1) Citizens have an important role in speaking up to the government, especially to ask for their own and community's needs, and 2) Rights are not gifts from governments, and it is acceptable for citizens to demand for their rights to be fulfilled. We also found that two groups were particularly responsive towards these narratives: married women with kids, who are more likely to be communally connected, and urban youths aged 18-24, who are more likely to mobilise for a cause. To test the effectiveness of these narratives further, we aim to conduct an online survey experiment using RCT on the two groups identified in the FGD. Our treatments will frame participation in civic actions in these narratives, affirming the message that holding the government accountable is acceptable, necessary, and a form of love for one’s country. We also intend to test the extent that paternalistic/family state (FS) beliefs, perception on the role of government (RG) (e.g., as caretaker rather than empowered by people), political efficacy (personal and collective/PCE), and politicised identification (PI) further contextualise the likelihood of participating in civic actions. Broadly, we ask three research questions: 1) Does framing civic action in the narrative of rights and patriotism increase the likelihood of participation in civic actions? 2) Is this likelihood of participation in civic action affected by individual level political/collective efficacy and politicised identification? 3) Is this likelihood of participation in civic action affected by existing beliefs of Indonesia as a family state and perceptions on the role of government? We aim to conduct Multiple Hypotheses Testing (MHT) to answer these research questions. We expect that participants exposed to these treatments would be more likely to express intention to respond positively to a call to action - in our case, to report grievances to the online application 'Lapor Sesama Warga', which managed public complaints. Furthermore, we expect that higher levels of PCE and PI would amplify the effects of the treatments. However, we also expect that higher levels of FS beliefs and specific perceptions of RG would reduce the effects of the treatments. The survey experiment will involve 8,000 participants recruited online via survey platform Swayable. The experiment will involve four treatment groups with four corresponding control groups, where the treatment groups will be exposed to a 1-minute video describing a problem – two of which will also view a collective action-based solution.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Social Media and Politics Political Theory and Democracy Electoral Systems and Political Participation

Publication details

Journal / source
Open Science Framework
Publication date
1 April 2026
Language
EN