Transitioning from the History of Science to the History of Knowledge: Performativity, Resistance, and the Asymmetry of “Nature” and “Society”

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Kenji Ito
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

This paper develops a conceptual framework for rewriting the history of science as a history of knowledge without presupposing a prior divide between “nature” and “society.” Drawing on Daston, Latour, Barnes, Callon, MacKenzie, Pickering, Butler, and Hacking, it asks how we can theorise both the continuity and the historical asymmetry between engineering/natural-science disciplines and the humanities and social sciences. I propose a three-layered model of performativity: (1) object-level “Barnesian” performativity based on bootstrapped induction and the interplay of N- and S-type predicates; (2) discipline- and network-level “Callon–MacKenzie” performativity, where theories and models help to shape the very markets and practices they describe; and (3) identity-level “Butler–Hacking” performativity and looping effects, exemplified by the Japanese bun/ri (“science”/“humanities”) divide as a powerful device of classification and self-identification. Across these layers I introduce two axes, performativity and resistance, that allow us to understand natural and human sciences as forming a gradient rather than an essential dichotomy. The article advances conjectural hypotheses rather than empirical claims, offering a set of concepts for future case studies in the history of knowledge and suggesting a move from representational “mirror” metaphors of knowledge towards diffractive ones inspired by Haraway and Barad.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Diverse Historical and Scientific Studies Historical Studies and Socio-cultural Analysis History of Science and Natural History

Publication details

Journal / source
Memoirs of the Faculty of Letters Kyoto University
Volume
65
Pages
153–206
Publication date
1 March 2026
Language
EN