ヤーコブソン ノ カンユ ヘーゲル ノ キゴウ プラトン ノ アトランティス キオク ト ソウゾウリョク ノ セイジ ケイザイガク ヒハン ジョセツ 6
Summary
No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.
Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.Abstract
This article is the sixth (Part VI) and the final part of a series. Alloying philosophy, psychoanalysis, and cultural studies, this series articulates the relationship between the essential nature of Western philosophyʼs metaphysical method of dialectics and the structure of memory in human beings. Covering Western philosophers, from ancient to modern, and quoting social, cultural, and psychopathological materials, this series elucidated the nature of memory in the neurotypical (NT), that is, the so-called normal, in the majority of human beings. As a conclusion, the author elucidates that it is “the otherness,” which always and already permeates the normal and stable working of memory, and frames the structure and content of the ego. In other words, the heteronomous nature of memory and imagination of typically developed individuals is depicted. Part I traced the position of the imagination, from Augustine to Descartes, and Part II traced its position in Kant and Heidegger. Part III examined Hegelʼs theory of the imagination with precision. Hegel transformed the Kantian productive imagination into an imagination that made “sign.” Part IV examined what “sign” and “mechanical memory” were in Hegel and discussed the enigma of the synchronized function of “sign-making fantasy.” Part V explored the riddle of “sign-making fantasy” and discussed the theoretical possibility of a “pseudo-synchronic circuit” that synchronized our fantasies, using contemporary linguistics and psychology. This Part VI, by reexamining Jakobsonʼs famous paper on two types of aphasia, equates Hegelʼs “sign” with what Jakobson calls “metonymy.” According to Jakobsonʼs classification, aphasia can be categorized into two distinct types based on the selection-combination axis. Individuals exhibiting “selection” deficits are characterized by pseudometonymical language impairments, while those with “combination” deficits demonstrate pseudometaphorical deficiencies. In the contemporary context, these phenomena can be associated with autism and schizophrenia. From Jakobsonʼs theoretical framework, two impairments in language operation are abstracted: the failure to detect the context presupposed by others and the failure to maintain oneʼs context against othersʼ contexts. Jacobsonʼs work implicitly succeeds in drawing out the nature of language in normal/typical development as a kind of “social metonymy.” This connects with Hegelʼs “sign.” Additionally, the endnote addresses the reversal terminology for metaphor and metonymy between Jakobson and Lacan. The final section discusses Platoʼs attempt, as argued by Lacan, to transform Socrates from a mediator into the first metonym and supreme philosopher. Interestingly, the Atlantis that Plato used as a metaphor resurfaced as a powerful metonym in late 19th-century spiritualism, paving the way for the popularity of ancient civilizations in the late 1960s. As global capitalism spread, people sought to recall the memory of a lost super-civilization – a future that had arrived. Dänikenʼs ancient astronaut theory capitalized on this wave of imagination. However, this is a “blank memory,” resulting from the communicative power of commodities, made possible by a combination of imagination, memory, and empathy. This combination is a product of the imaginative transformation circuit – the “pseudosynchronic circuit” that we extract from Hegelʼs theory of memory throughout this series.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Philosophy and Theoretical Science
Memory
History
Trauma
Identity
Nietzsche
Schopenhauer
and Hegel
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Institutional Repositories DataBase (IRDB)
- Volume
- 52
- Pages
- 63–94
- Publication date
- 18 March 2026
- Language
- JA