Navigating the Paradox of Ethical Transgression: Managerial Robin Hoodism and the Boundaries of Supererogatory Justice Enactment

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Jonathan Westover
Cited by: 0
References: 21

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Managerial Robin Hoodism—the unauthorized redistribution of organizational resources to remedy perceived workplace injustice—occupies an ambiguous position in organizational ethics. This behavior simultaneously violates formal authority structures while pursuing morally laudable ends, creating classification difficulties for observers attempting to evaluate its moral status. Drawing on philosophical theories of supererogation and organizational justice enactment frameworks, we investigate how observers classify Robin Hoodism across the moral categories of obligatory, supererogatory, and prohibited action. Through three factorial vignette experiments with 423 working adults evaluating 847 systematically varied scenarios, we examine how situational characteristics and reflective processing shape these classifications. Study 1 establishes that observers most frequently classify Robin Hoodism as supererogatory (beyond duty) rather than obligatory or prohibited, though substantial variation exists across conditions. Study 2 demonstrates that injustice severity and victim marginalization shift classifications toward obligation, with moral outrage partially mediating these effects. Study 3 reveals that structured moral reflection significantly increases obligatory classifications at the expense of supererogatory judgments, suggesting that apparent optionality may reflect organizational framing rather than genuine moral discretion. We introduce the distinction between thin supererogation—apparent optionality that tends to shift toward perceived obligation under reflection—and thick supererogation—perceived optionality that remains stable under extended moral consideration. This distinction offers a conceptual vocabulary for understanding how organizational contexts may shape moral perception. It is important to emphasize that this distinction describes patterns in observer judgments rather than adjudicating the genuine moral status of actions—a point we develop throughout. Theoretical implications for justice enactment research and practical implications for organizational ethics are discussed, along with important limitations regarding the descriptive nature of these findings.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Ethics in Business and Education Job Satisfaction and Organizational Behavior Psychology of Moral and Emotional Judgment

Publication details

Journal / source
Preprints.org
Publication date
26 March 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Preprint