Improving and Measuring Water Oxidation Catalyst Viability

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: USDOE Office of Science (SC), Colton J. Breyer, CA (United States) San Diego State Univ., Miguel Ibanez, Douglas B. Grotjahn
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

A major challenge that limits the efficiency of the overall water splitting reaction is the oxidation half-reaction, a process that releases oxygen and electrons, which in turn can reduce either protons or carbon dioxide to make hydrogen or carbon-based fuel. In this project, the major objectives are to increase the stability of water oxidation catalysts (WOCs), to develop ways to study catalyst stability, and to enable WOC performance in acidic media. The project was originally led by Principal Investigator Dr. Douglas Grotjahn. Tragically, Dr. Grotjahn passed away in 2023. In 2024, Dr. Jing Gu took over as PI and guided the project through a challenging transition period. With a no-cost extension into 2025, the team successfully stabilized the research effort, achieving a smooth and productive transition that allowed work to continue effectively. Other students from the original group made smooth transitions to join other research labs to continue their PhD research. Between 2024-2025, we got four manuscripts published, and below I will explain each project in detail: Among mononuclear WOC, ruthenium catalysts incorporating 2,2’-bipyridine-6,6’-dicarboxylato ligands (bda2−) (Figure 1a) with ceric ammonium nitrate, Ce (IV), as a sacrificial oxidant have shown impressive water oxidation rates. Although the rate of water oxidation catalysis is important, in the long run, the durability of WOC remains a challenge. For example, there is evidence that at pH 7, the tetradentate bda ligand will dissociate from the metal centre in the presence of a sacrificial oxidant, photosensitizer, and light, to create a trinuclear complex. To address the stability problems mentioned above, here we introduce a family of complexes with a new pentadentate ligand bcpq2−(Figure 1b). The P(V) center of the phosphinic acid moiety of the pentadentate ligand bears a quinoline side arm that is designed to reduce axial ligand loss. As far as we are aware, there is no previous example attempting to use the extra valency on P(V) to connect a linker arm in WOC. The bcpq2− ligand introduces several benefits, including (1) facile synthesis (2) the Ru catalysts exhibit impressive water oxidation activity using Ce (IV) in acid, and at pH 7 electrochemically, (3) following a single site mechanism, and (4) the pentadentate bcpq catalyst remains homogeneous in bulk electrolysis experiments at pH 7, whereas the bda analog becomes heterogeneous. This work is published on ChemCatChem 2024 (ChemCatChem 2024, 16, e202301644) In addition to the two common water-oxidation catalysis mechanisms (I2M and WNA) already mentioned, a third potential mechanism, the oxide relay (OR), has recently been proposed. OR was computationally shown to be energetically favorable when compared to WNA and I2M for the catalyst species B. In this work, A series of ruthenium complexes containing both a carboxylate and a sulfonate group were synthesized and tested as water oxidation catalysts. These catalysts achieved comparable rates and higher TON under sacrificial-oxidant conditions than their dicarboxylate counterparts. Moreover, they exhibited improved electrochemical performance under neutral and moderately acidic conditions compared to the dicarboxylate catalyst while operating at a sufficiently low potential. Our results have also provided insights into the varying mechanisms for the same catalyst under sacrificial oxidant and electrochemical conditions or at different concentrations. Based on the second-order dependence of the rate on the catalyst concentration in the CAN experiments, we infer that catalysts 1 a and 2 a should undergo I2M under sacrificial oxidant conditions. In contrast, under electrochemical conditions, the essential role of buffer base in achieving significant catalytic activity and the absence of isotope-substituted catalyst in experiments using 18O labelled water suggest that WNA should be the dominant mechanism under our tested conditions, although the predominant mechanism may change as the electrochemical potential varies. The mechanisms for catalysts 1 b and 2 b are debatable and could also vary as the reaction condition changes. However, for 1 b, the initial rate is clearly first-order with respect to catalyst concentration in sacrificial oxidant experiments, indicating that I2M is not favorable under that condition. Computational results based on 2 a suggest that WNA is the most favorable mechanism energetically compared to OR and I2M under the assumption that the O−O bond formation step is the RDS. This work was published in 2024 (Eur. J. Inorg. Chem. 2024, 2, e202400265) by Jake Kerkhof, a previous graduate student of Dr. Grotjahn, with Prof. Yuezhi Mao, a collaborator of Dr. Grotjahn. Recently, Doug’s group has developed a Ru-based water oxidation catalyst (WOC) with pendant sulfonate (1, Ru(4′-X-terpyridine)(phenanthroline-SO3)OTf (X = H, 1a) that shows high activity under both sacrificial oxidant (CAN, Ce(NH4)2(NO3)6, CeIV) and electrocatalytic conditions, in both acidic and neutral media. Here, we demonstrate that the functionalization of the 4′-X-terpyridine ligand with an electron-donating substituent X = OEt (1b) makes potentials of RuII/RuIII redox catalysis more negative, whereas when X = NO2 (1c) and CF3 (1d), potentials are more positive. For 1b, full conversion of the sacrificial oxidant CeIV occurred in 0.4 h (7 h for 1a), with an initial rate of 2.07 μmol O2 s–1 and a turnover frequency of 7.6 s–1, which is 30-fold faster than that for 1a at [cat]0 = 20 μM. Under electrocatalytic conditions, water oxidation by 1b is three times faster than that by the parent catalyst 1a at close to the same potential. Extensive computations have identified differences in the initial PCET steps of water oxidation by catalysts 1a, 1b, and 1d and have demonstrated an increased probability of O2 formation via the oxide relay pathway in the order 1b < 1a < 1d. This work was recently published in Inorganic Chemistry 2025 (Inorganic Chemistry, 2025, 64, 7, 3188-3195) There are two main methods for rate constant analysis: foot-of-the-wave analysis (FOWA) and limiting current analysis. Both have limitations in multielectron and multiproton reactions, such as water oxidation, motivating us to develop a new method. To avoid the issues with FOWA and limiting current methods for non-ideal waveshapes, a new method for obtaining Ecat for the use in obtaining i_cat and hence kcat is developed. This method capitalizes on the linear relation observed in equation 1(i_lim/i_p =2.241∙n_cat/n_p ∙((k_cat∙R∙T)/(n_p∙F∙v))^(1/2) [1] ) of i_cat/i_p vs 1/√v from purely kinetic catalysis and the linear relation of base concentration during base assisted WNA observed in equation 2 (k_cat=[B]∙k_B+ k_(H_2 O) [2]). Because this new method is focused on extracting values from catalysts in the absence of true limiting current, Ecat will be substituted with E′cat, which is defined as the potential at which the observed current at various scan rates and buffer concentrations behaves most like that of limiting current. This method was tested on four mononuclear, homogeneous ruthenium water-oxidation catalysts, all of which exhibited deviations from a purely kinetic regime. We believe that our new method provides an alternative to the well-documented problems of existing methods of analysis. This work was published recently in ChemSusChem (ChemSusChem, 2025, 18, e202500778). The project also made important contributions to education and workforce development as well. One notable success was PhD student Colton J. Breyer, who graduated with his PhD degree in Sep. 2024 from the joint doctoral program of UCDS/SDSU. His thesis, entitled "Instrumentation and Methodology for the Challenging Analysis of Water Oxidation Stability and Performance," advanced techniques for evaluating catalysts in energy-related reactions like water splitting. It trained early-career scientists, including a Hispanic PhD student, Miguel Ibanez, who synthesized new ligands, passed his candidacy exam, and is progressing toward his degree under Dr. Yong Yan's mentorship at SDSU. This DOE project helped Colton to successfully finish his PhD, and Miguel transitioned to a new research group. By providing mentorship during a difficult leadership change and supporting diverse trainees, the project strengthened the next generation of chemists. Despite the challenges from the PI transition, this DOE-supported project enabled recovery and meaningful progress. This award advanced fundamental knowledge in catalysis, promoted sustainable chemistry, and supported education and student success— outcomes that enhance U.S. scientific capabilities and benefit society.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Electrocatalysts for Energy Conversion Advanced Photocatalysis Techniques Metal-Catalyzed Oxygenation Mechanisms

Publication details

Journal / source
OSTI OAI (U.S. Department of Energy Office of Scientific and Technical Information)
Publication date
4 February 2026
Language
EN