Abstract
There are currently 5456 osteopaths registered in the UK (Statistics - General Osteopathic Council, 10/03/2026), regulated by the General Osteopathic Council (GOsC). The primary role of GOsC is to improve patient safety and support osteopaths. Complaints around professional boundary violations are a consistent feature of the National Council for Osteopathic Research's Concerns and Complaints Report ((Fawkes and Draper-Rodi, 2023, 2025). A professional boundary violation occurs when the relationship and interactions between the osteopath and patient extend beyond what is clinically necessary. This study aims to use Professional Conduct Committee (PCC) hearing decisions to identify patterns in the types of professional boundary violations that result in a PCC hearing and the outcomes they generate. Additionally, it will look for contextual and contributing factors that surround the boundary violation and map these against existing boundary theories such as the Boundary Continuum ((Davidson, 2005a) and the Slippery Slope theory (Holder and Schenthal, 2007).Research Questions1. What types of professional and sexual boundary violations are escalated to PCC hearing?2. PCC hearings can have one of several outcomes, what patterns exist in the outcome of the hearing and the related boundary violation?3. What can PCC decisions reveal about the processes and contexts contributing to professional boundary violations in osteopathy?Data collection methods This study will use qualitative document analysis of PCC decisions. These documents are a regulatory account of professional boundary violations and provide insight into the context surrounding the event. PCC decisions are published on the GOsC website in accordance with their publication policy, (Fitness to Practise Publication Policy - General Osteopathic Council, 2023). An extract is included the attached project protocol. I will identify and download the decisions that are publicly available, these decisions will form the first part of the dataset. I will conduct and initial review of the documents and the inclusion and exclusion criteria will be applied. InclusionDecided in the last 10 years, professional or Sexual Boundaries mentioned in the decision at any stage, relational issues mentioned in the decision , Osteopathic Practice standard D2 or D8 in decisions prior to 2019, all outcomes, all sanctions ExclusionOlder than 10 years, No mention of boundaries, No mention of relational issues The inclusion and exclusion criteria may develop as the project progresses. The protocol will be updated if this occurs.Following this initial review, a framework of search terms will be developed and shared with the Head of Fitness to Practise at GOsC to facilitate the identification of additional historic decisions. Access to these has been agreed under a data sharing agreement between the Open University and GOsC.Any new PCC decisions published during the study including those scheduled to take place in 2026 will be included in the dataset where they meet the criteria.Data Analysis will proceed in several steps, beginning with familiarisation with dataset.The source data will be uploaded to NVivo and relevant information extracted. Below are details that I expect to extract, these may change as the analysis progresses.Data Category ExampleComplaint characteristics Oversharing, undressing, inappropriate language, sexual boundariesPatient factors Gender, age, vulnerabilities eg physical or mental health conditions,Practitioner factors Gender, age, time on register, FTP history,Outcome of hearing Unprofessional conduction (UPC) did not occur. UPC did occur.Sanction Admonishment, conditions of practice, suspension, removal.Contextual Factors Workload, professional isolation, health, life stress, length of professional relationship. The extracted data will be analytically redescribed using concepts from existing boundary literature and the theories of the Slippery Slope and Boundary Continuum. This involves the translation of descriptive events in the documents into meaningful categories. e.g. role confusion, informal practice, professional isolation.Across cases the data will be analysed to identify patterns in contextual factors that could signal underlying mechanisms.Through a process of retroductive inference, generative mechanisms will be theorised. This process is iterative and analysis will go back and forth between the steps and the dataset is better understood.