Book Review: Micheál Ó Floinn, Lindsay Farmer, Julia Hörnle and David Ormerod CBE, KC (Eds) Transformations in Criminal Jurisdiction: Extraterritoriality and Enforcement (Oxford: Hart 2023), 400 Pages
Summary
No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.
Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.Abstract
The international law of jurisdiction is concerned with regulating the exercise of power by states -where, how, over whom.The modern corpus of jurisdictional law is generally understood to have emanated from the exercise of criminal jurisdiction by states, and was developed as a way of mitigating and resolving conflicts that arose between states when they exerted their criminal law powers.This is unsurprising, given that the criminal law reflects values held closely by the populaces of individual states, and thus is viewed as a domain where sovereign interests dominate.The problems, moreover, are particularly acute: states are territorial entities that object to interference in their sovereign domains, yet also have interest in regulating matters that extend beyond their borders.Until recently, the international law of jurisdiction was under-studied and under-theorized, the criminal branch no less than any other.This was particularly unfortunate given the two seismic challenges to that law that developed in the late 20th century: the onslaught of globalization and the rise of the internet.The movement of people, conduct, communication, and goods across borders, combined with the inherent territorial porousness of 'cyberspace,' 1 continue to challenge in this moment, a quarter of the way through the 21st century.The very notion of 'territory,' the central foundation of the law of jurisdiction, has begun to seem inadequate, for the purposes of both law-making and law enforcing.Once again, the criminal law space is in the centre of the fire, as states try to apply older paradigms to new challenges.This is the dilemma, and the doctrinal opportunity, taken up by the editors and authors of Transformations in Criminal Jurisdiction: Extraterritoriality and Enforcement. 2 Originally a set of papers presented at a conference held in April 2021, the revised and updated chapters of this book leap enthusiastically into the most challenging issues faced by lawmakers, law enforcers, observers, and theorizers in the area.As the editors note, the collection seeks to 'address some of these transformations of criminal jurisdiction, combining theoretical and practical questions so as to develop new perspectives on jurisdiction and the criminal law.' 3 While the topics are excitingly disparate, the editors and authors alike are powered by a consensus that the law of criminal jurisdiction is in some danger of coming apart at the seams, and collectively they put an admirable level of skill, thought, and energy into description, analysis, critique, and re-imagining.In terms of both quality and focus, collections of conference papers have an uneven track record, but the editors and authors here have skilfully woven a set of papers on related but disparate topics around a distinct set of themes that have immediacy.The volume opens with a strong introductory chapter by the four editors -'strong' because it contains a very lucid delimitation of rules and concepts, and avoids the flabbiness and overly theoretical flavour that often undermines writing on jurisdiction.Having acknowledged that the primary challenges to the exercise of
Fields of Study & Subjects
Conflict of Laws and Jurisdiction
International Law and Human Rights
European Criminal Justice and Data Protection
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Transnational Criminal Law Review
- Volume
- 4
- Issue
- 2
- Publication date
- 9 January 2026
- Language
- EN